Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

What's effed up on my machine?

  • Bad CPU

  • Bad GPU

  • Thermal pasting on either/or CPU/GPU

  • Some other mainboard issues (power IC? capacitor?)

  • Other weird ****


Results are only viewable after voting.

motochan

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Sep 24, 2017
19
5
Singapore
Hey guys, I have a i9 octa-core 2.4ghz with 64GB ram, 5500M 8GB DDR6, 4TB config that is ~6 months old. Recently, I've been noticing a really weird behaviour after investigating why my 16" MBP is displaying graphical glitches after playing Civ6 via Steam for under 5 mins. Resolution in-game is 1792x1120 with Medium settings and no AA, nothing crazy.

Screenshot 2020-07-05 00.57.59.pngScreenshot 2020-07-04 23.35.35.pngScreenshot 2020-07-04 23.32.57.png

When this happens, the entire system is unrecoverable; I tried force-quitting Civ 6 but there's just too much corruption to properly see what's going on.

I've run this again with the laptop on a table surface, and it is the same thing.

My ambient temperature is around 28C. The highest the onboard sensor seems to be able to record is 100C. CPU 1, 2 and 3 hit 100C during the Gathering Storm graphics test in Civ 6, while CPU 4 hit 95C and CPU 5 98C, and CPU 6, 7 and 8 were at 91C. Is that normal? I don't ever recall my Macbook Pros of old ever going so high.

I've done the null Terminal load test with 16 separate Terminal windows each running a thread, and temps never got so high, roughly 3-5C lower than the above. I've run Cinebench on a 60min loop with no issues. I've run the Apple Hardware Test (AHT) myself (press-D on Apple screen) with no issues, and reached out to Apple Support where the tech got me to run the Apple Service Test (AST), also seemingly with no issues. I'm slated to go into my nearest Apple authorised service centre in a week's time to run deeper hardware-level tests, but this is bugging me enough to type it up for the community here, in case someone hits the same problem as I did.

I suspect it's a combination of poorly applied thermal paste at factory and a bad GPU. I'm surprised Civ 6 can extract that much more out of the hardware than the other steps I've taken! What gives?
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2020-07-05 08.59.01.png
    Screenshot 2020-07-05 08.59.01.png
    727.7 KB · Views: 166
I was shocked to see my 16" MBP pull a total of 118W, 112W and 102W at the 3 highest peaks of the power draw during my latest Civ 6 run in an air-conditioned room of 24C ambient, roughly 4-5C lower than my previous runs. It still shows the same graphical corruption, albeit after a longer period of time.

Screenshot 2020-07-05 10.00.31.png

When looking at the Radeon die, it goes up to 82C peak; it's probably thermal constrained by the CPU anyway.

Screenshot 2020-07-05 10.00.50.png
 
I think a Bootcamp / Windows Civ 6 test would conclude whether it's hardware or just macos

But my sympathies are with you, it's a downer, and these are unnecessarily hot machines :/
 
Try some other games? Knowing Civ 6 my first guess would be a bug in the code.

Your temperature is absolutely fine.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.