2 volumes showing up during Catalina installation - both drives different name ?

[4sallypat]

Stuck here: a clean installation of Catalina onto a 2012 MBA which has a 64GB SSD which I am listing on eBay to sell.

The MBA had previously been on High Sierra and after booting from a USB Catalina boot disk, Disk Utility reports 2 identical sized volumes. One says "Macintosh HD" the other says "Macintosh HD - Data"

They are being erased for APFS volumes.

When I try to install Catalina, I get a choice between 2 drives - both 64GB

Anyone know why this is happening and which to choose for the OSX installation ?

 

[junkw]

choose the first
is it catalina 10.15 or 10.15.2?

 

[IowaLynn]

Schematic APFS

Carbon Copy Cloner | macOS Backup Software | Bombich Software

www.bombich.com

 

[4sallypat]

Catalina 10.15.1

I just installed it and now I see 2 hard drives.

Is this normal ?

[automerge]1576945871[/automerge]

choose the first
is it catalina 10.15 or 10.15.2?

 

[junkw]

on 10.15.2 I don't see 2 drives

 

[revmacian]

I'm on a 2019 MacBook Air running macOS Catalina 10.15.2 and I only see 1 HD on my desktop, labeled "Macintosh HD". I upgraded from Mojave (no clean install).

From what I understand, the drive labeled "Macintosh HD - Data" is normal for Catalina.

 

[junkw]

they just forgot to hide it

 

[honestone33]

Yeah, there are two internal "drives" designated with Catalina. They are both the same size, but in actuality, that "same size" is just shared space between the two "partitions".

 

[ApfelKuchen]

https://support.apple.com/HT210650 explains that there are now two Macintosh HD volumes in Catalina. One is a read-only volume containing the OS (for greater security), the other is read/write for data.

 

[4sallypat]

Thanks all for your wonderful assistance!

I found this:
By doing an UPGRADE from High Sierra to Catalina, there is only 1 drive that shows (like normal).

And doing a full CLEAN install (USB Boot) to Catalina results in 2 drives.

Interesting ......

 

[honestone33]

Thanks all for your wonderful assistance!

I found this:
By doing an UPGRADE from High Sierra to Catalina, there is only 1 drive that shows (like normal).

And doing a full CLEAN install (USB Boot) to Catalina results in 2 drives.

Interesting ......

Myself, I did a fresh, clean installation of OS 10.15.2 from an external SSD containing a SuperDuper! bootable backup, not from a Flash Drive. But I suspect that should make no difference.

Also, I can only "see" the two volumes via Disk Utility. Only one of them shows up on the desktop after booting either of my Macs.

 

[gilby101]

Is this normal ?

No it is not. Unless you look with Disk Utility, you should only 'see' the combined disk Macintosh HD.

Do the install again, by booting to recovery mode (or from a USB install disk), erase the whole disk using Disk Utility and then install.

 

[IowaLynn]

Sounds like the conversion of the system cluster still left a blessed system on the - Data volume.

I assume using Startup Disk to set - Data as bout volume will fail.

 

[honestone33]

No it is not. Unless you look with Disk Utility, you should only 'see' the combined disk Macintosh HD.

Do the install again, by booting to recovery mode (or from a USB install disk), erase the whole disk using Disk Utility and then install.

You can also "see" both of them when one runs EtreCheck. I just did it. And yes, I can also see both of them with Disk Utility.

From what I remember, both of them will appear on the desktop if I boot my machine from its SuperDuper! backup on my external SSD. That desktop, of course, "belongs" to the backup volume.

 

[Peadogie]

@4sallypat, can you boot your MBA? if so post a screenshot of your drive from Disc Utility (click on the view button and choose Show All Devices). it should look something like this (my drive is named Catalina):

If you can't boot your MBA I would follow the advice gilby101 posted.

 

[IowaLynn]

When did SuperDuper get the ok for Catalina?

 

[Peadogie]

When did SuperDuper get the ok for Catalina?

Their blog says 11/26/19.

 

[honestone33]

Their blog says 11/26/19.

Yes, that was the date.

When did SuperDuper get the ok for Catalina?

One can enter the search term SuperDuper! in your browser's address line, and you'll get this (assuming you are using Google as your search engine):

Super Duper Publications

Super Duper Publications makes fun, practical materials for speech language pathology (SLP), autism, articulation, auditory processing, vocabulary, speech therapy, learning disabilities, grammar, assessment, oral motor, apraxia, phonology, reading comprehension, IEP, early intervention, and...

www.google.com

Then, clicking on the first link brings up this:

SuperDuper!

That is what I kept doing.

You can also click on Check for Update... under the SuperDuper! heading after launching it.

 

[IowaLynn]

I was holding off if SD! and happy with CCC. Hadn't seen or read anything especially here. And maybe a month is enough time for issues never dreamed of from surfacing, like the OP has.

 

[honestone33]

I was holding off if SD! and happy with CCC. Hadn't seen or read anything especially here. And maybe a month is enough time for issues never dreamed of from surfacing, like the OP has.

I actually made a post about that new version on November 26th:

New Version of SuperDuper! Released!

OK, V3.3 of SuperDuper!, with Catalina compatibility, has been released: https://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/SuperDuperDescription.html The download link is on the right of the page, at the end of the paragraph entitled "v3.3 now available". Note also that this version of compatible with...

forums.macrumors.com

Also, it is now at version 3.3.1, but everything is working fine. I have been using the new version for my past 2 backups: a week and a half ago with both of my Mojave-based Macs, and yesterday with my Catalina-based Mac Book Air.