Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jfcates

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 6, 2005
19
2
Maryland, USA
2009 firmware updated to 2010. Delided w3670 xeons to upgraded 8 core to 12 core. Each new cpu will boot up in cpu A with fast fan, but when either one installed in cpu A and B I get a kernel panic.

kernelPanic.jpg


Suggestions please.
 
I may be wrong, but you need "X" Xeons for paired use. "W" processors will not work.

So you need a pair of X5680 or X5690s to work (or 5650, etc).
 
I may be wrong, but you need "X" Xeons for paired use. "W" processors will not work.

So you need a pair of X5680 or X5690s to work (or 5650, etc).

OMG :( I hope your are wrong, but if you're right = what a BIG dumb mistake. Can anyone else "chime" in on this please?
 
OMG :( I hope your are wrong, but if you're right = what a BIG dumb mistake. Can anyone else "chime" in on this please?

Ouch because I have never done a delid process but sounds like a bit of a pain in the arse! Yea you delid on CPUs that cannot run in a dual CPU system. So that work was in vain. Unfortunately this looks like an important detail you missed. Give this thread a real good look over on the whole topic. You need two CPUs that have "Dual Xeon" capability. W3670 is just "Xeon" so only works in a single CPU system

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/mac-pro-cpu-compatibility-list.1954766/
 
Ok! :( Thanks to all who responded. I guess I'll try to sell them on Craigslist; don't know if there's a market for these delided. Worth a shot anyway. At least I know I can delid without a problem, but what an expensive "testing method." I put the the originals back in and booted without issue.
 
I wrote and posted this over 4 years ago:

Intel's Part Number Descriptions Explained here:

Intel has changed what the leading Alpha means. The change happened when going from the 35XX (55XX) to the 36XX (56XX) series.

In the older series it meant:

E = Enterprise and CPUs with a TDP of 80 Watts
X = Accelerated and CPUs with a TDP of 95 Watts
W = Workstation and CPUs with a TDP of 130 Watts

and in every case the leading numeric after the alpha meant:

3 = for single CPU use only (1 x I/O Bus)
5 = for dual CPU use, but will work in single CPU applications (2 x I/O Bus)

In the later series, the above nomenclature rules stayed constant EXCEPT - The "X" prefix means accelerated (95 or 130 watt TDP) and is only used on CPUs with a 2 x I/O bus. The "W" prefix is now used only in the single CPU series (1 X I/O Bus).

In any case in both series, the meaning of leading numeric after the alpha has remained the same. A "3" for CPUs with a 1 x I/O bus and a "5" for CPUs with a 2 X I/O Bus.

I hope this makes sense to you. It took me awhile to figure it out.

Lou
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.