OK, now that we know that, WHAT VERSION of the OS do you want to install on the 2009 MBPro?
A 2009 Mac CANNOT do "internet recovery".
Probably your best bet is to do this:
a. Download a fresh copy of the OS installer onto one of your other Macs. Make sure it's in the "applications" folder. DO NOT ATTEMPT TO RUN IT YET.
b. Download the CORRECT VERSION of DiskMaker X from here:
diskmakerx.com
(What version you download depends on which version of the OS you're trying to install)
c. Get a USB flash drive 16gb or larger (8gb might work if that's all you have)
d. Erase the flash drive to "Mac OS extended with journaling enabled, GUID partition format" (using Disk Utility)
e. Use Diskmaker X to create a bootable flash drive (takes only a few clicks and some time).
f. Use the bootable flash drive to boot the 2009 MBPro.
g. BEFORE you attempt to install, use Disk Utility to ERASE the contents of the internal drive to Mac OS extended with journaling enabled, GUID partition format. THIS WILL DESTROY ANY FILES ON THE DRIVE !!!
h. NOW open the OS installer and attempt a clean install onto the MBPro.