Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Other 8 plus vs xr
- Thread starter Tentenmiu
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It’s hard to tell you which is better due to the fact my preferences differ from yours. I like the X design so I would choose the XR. Others want the home button and the better screen ratio so they would choose the 8+.
All depends on your needs and preferences.
All depends on your needs and preferences.
I absolutely love my 8 Plus and I would not otherwise budge from it, but I’ve been wanting Apple to give iPhones the ability to record videos with stereo sound for a few years now. They finally did so I am trading my silver 8 Plus for the XS, though I would be happy to get an Xr if the modems in the Xr were the same as the ones in the XS. I live and travel in places where I need the little extra oomph the XS modems have.
I absolutely love the display on my 8 Plus though, more than even most OLED displays I’ve seen, so I’m keeping my Product Red iphone. (Yeah I had two, but I didn’t pay much for the silver one).
I think the camera improvements for the Xr are probably significant if taking pictures and videos are important to you. Other than that, the display on the 8 Plus is actually probably better. Performance on the 8 Plus is certainly fine. I’ve had no complaints! Good luck on your choice.
I have an 8+ now, but I disagree that it is better in “every aspect.” It is hard to tell until there is a full review, but the XR has:
- Larger screen
- Smaller body
- Better battery life
- Improved single camera
- Faster processor
- More customizable colors
As someone who likes a big screen but thinks the 8+ is a tad bigger than ideal, the first two are key
I’m not including things like FaceId, which some claim is better
Year over year, the XR at $749 for 64G or $800 for 128G is a MUCH better value than the was last year
I feel like the XR takes a big hit to its rear camera. You lose 2x optical zoom and the 10x digital zoom goes down to 5x. Portrait lighting effects Stage and Stage Mono are not available for the rear camera.
However, the XR gets advanced bokeh, Depth Control, and Smart HDR. For video recording, the XR gains extended dynamic range up to 30 fps as well as stereo recording.
The XR also gets a front-facing (selfie) camera that is on par with the X/Xs. So, you can do Face ID, Animoji and Memoji.
If you're a fan of 3D Touch, the XR doesn't have it.
So, if you use your front-facing (selfie) camera more than the rear-facing camera, the XR is probably right up your alley.
However, the XR gets advanced bokeh, Depth Control, and Smart HDR. For video recording, the XR gains extended dynamic range up to 30 fps as well as stereo recording.
The XR also gets a front-facing (selfie) camera that is on par with the X/Xs. So, you can do Face ID, Animoji and Memoji.
If you're a fan of 3D Touch, the XR doesn't have it.
So, if you use your front-facing (selfie) camera more than the rear-facing camera, the XR is probably right up your alley.
This is my current plan. We'll see if that changes once I see the phones in person but that's what I'm thinking right now.
I do want to see how well the single-lens Portrait Mode works though on the XR.
1. I hate 3D Touch with a passion. I wish it would get removed from all iPhones eventually, since its presence just causes confusion for the developers, including Apple itself, in terms of the UI.
2. I too will miss the telephoto lens*, but I use it less on my 7 Plus than I originally expected. The main reason is the quality is just that much worse than the quality of the wide lens on that iPhone. If the XS is similar, with the quality of the wide being way better than the telephoto, then it's not as big of a loss.
If the telephoto's quality were as good as the wide, I'd probably have to man up and spend the extra cash on the XS Max.
BTW, the XR has the longest battery life of all three models, although it seems the Max is relatively close. The XS is by far the worst.
*It should be noted that when you choose the 2X zoom on a dual-lens iPhone, the iPhone will sometimes present a digitally zoomed image from the wide lens instead of using the actual telephoto lens, because sometimes the digitally zoomed image will be better quality.
It's true the X's telephoto is much better than the 7 Plus' telephoto, but it's still way worse than the X's wide angle, and thus the iPhone X still exhibits the same behaviour of sometimes choosing a digitally zoomed wide angle over the telephoto.
Last edited: