Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

dsemf

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jul 26, 2014
441
114
This image from bombich.com (CCC) provides a nice summary of disk changes introduced by Catalina.

partition volume.png


Catalina does not have two system partitions, it has two volumes, system and data, which are located in a volume group which is located in a container which is a disk partition.

DS
 

AddisonIII

macrumors regular
May 8, 2013
190
54
This image from bombich.com (CCC) provides a nice summary of disk changes introduced by Catalina.

View attachment 868380

Catalina does not have two system partitions, it has two volumes, system and data, which are located in a volume group which is located in a container which is a disk partition.

DS
My disk utility is showing 3 sections/partitions. 1st being HD,2 and 3rd showing as HD-Data. My understanding from Apple support is some people are seeing more than the 3 mine is showing. Not sure if
this is a problem for you or something your sharing so that other know what to look for.
 

dsemf

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jul 26, 2014
441
114
My disk utility is showing 3 sections/partitions. 1st being HD,2 and 3rd showing as HD-Data. My understanding from Apple support is some people are seeing more than the 3 mine is showing. Not sure if
this is a problem for you or something your sharing so that other know what to look for.
My "rant" was actually about incorrect terminology. It is not a problem, it just takes me a bit to mentally remap partition to volume when reading a post.

Since I can't upgrade to Catalina until Sunday due to availability requirements, I don't have a real life view yet.

If you are willing, I would be interested in seeing the terminal output from diskutil list and diskutil apfs list. If you do so, please wrap the results in a Code insert. The formatting is much better and scrollable.

DS
 

IowaLynn

macrumors 68020
Feb 22, 2015
2,145
589
APFS Volume Groups
In macOS Catalina, Apple introduced another new concept to the APFS filesystem: volume groups. This is more of a conceptual grouping of volumes within an APFS container, not a new sub-structure. Apple also greatly expanded the number of roles available for APFS volumes (now there are 16 unique roles). When you upgrade to Catalina, your current macOS system volume is renamed, e.g. to "Macintosh HD - Data", its role is set to Data, and then a new volume is added to your startup disk's APFS container with the System role and simultaneously grouped with the Data volume. The two volumes within that group share special bonds and receive special treatment from the Finder and from each volume's filesystem. From the user perspective, these two volumes are treated as a single, unified volume. If you take a look at Disk Utility, however, you'll see the two volumes as distinct, separate items.

...
firmlinks
To pull off the illusion of a single, unified volume, Apple added support to APFS for firmlinks. Like the name implies, a firmlink lies conceptually between a soft link and a hard link. That probably doesn't make them any more clear

Also,

It began to sink in and make sens after a second reading.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.