I'm kind of curious since the notices imply that it's 24.99 a year for 25,000 songs [tracks]. I've a huge converted classical music collection, almost all at 320kB.
Now it will be downgraded to 228 and what about the fact that I've 85,000 tracks? Extra fee? Not possible?
What about all of the songs that iTunes Match won't recognize that I've painstakingly edited the ID3 meta fields with?
iTunes disc recognition is already fairly limp when it comes to classical music, even though classical recordings include more recordings (particularly in the historical context) than pop, rock, dance, jazz, and hiphop combined.
I would say iTunes Match is not for you. Perhaps Google Music or Amazon Prime would be better. Google is free so far in beta for up to 20,000 tracks. Not sure about buying more space there.
I don't believe there is an option you can buy to allow iTunes Match to work with more songs.
Match is really all about, well, the "matching" part. I think Apple probably had to make a few concessions with the record companies in order to be allowed to do that. The song limit might be one of them.
As for me, iTunes Match is a welcome service.
I am not nearly as diligent in keeping my music collection organized as you are. I have thousands of crappy MP3s recorded from streaming radio, years ago (legally--no different than recording from a radio with a mic). The app I used, Total Recorder Pro, was pretty good about splitting the radio stream into separate tracks and auto-naming them (from player). But the stream itself back then was barely 128kbps and then re-encoded to MP3 for another loss. Ad the song lengths rarely match the officially released versions.
I was about to just delete those old MP3s when Match was announced.
I am beta testing Match and it has matched over 90% of those tracks which kind of surprised me.
I can now download those matched tracks in much better quality so for $25 it was a no brainer. All my iTunes store music that was bought when DRM was in place, but not updated to plus format, can be downloaded in higher quality without DRM too. In fact the songs downloaded from match are exactly like iTunes plus songs: no DRM per se but your Apple ID is embedded in the file.
I also like how it practically adds "syncing" to iTunes. I can keep my mb air nearly empty and still have the same look and feel of iTunes, with my entire library there if I want access to it. If I change a playlist on the Air the changes are propagated to my other mac, and iOS devices, right away.
So for me it seems worth it. But for you, honestly, does not seem like it is.
Michael