Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Are all Milanese ssteel created equal?

coolbreeze2 said:
This add says these inexpensive Milanese loops are made of woven stainless steel. So does that mean they are a just as good as the Milanese loops Apple sells?


https://www.groupon.com/deals/gg-mi...0f3559-9b6a-4558-b12d-da7217d59d2b_0_20171204
Click to expand...

Apple uses 316 L stainless steel for the link bracelet and Milanese loop. I didn't see anywhere on this listing that was indicated what type of steel they use. Regardless, it won't be the quality of Apples Milanese loop.
 
In the 0 Series Days the 3rd Party offerings were crap.

Can you tell the difference in these photos?
19339889266_4c35653567_b.jpg

18745339103_f02fe3fb0a_b.jpg

19178404028_c5137bc6d7_b.jpg

18743436804_4c0d4a7335_b.jpg

19178350470_6eab075daa_b.jpg

18743446664_6db31cb7f7_b.jpg

18745340873_2e94aa12ee_b.jpg
19178344270_8a9a97226a_b.jpg

19370028571_fbc3417cec_b.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarlJ and poppe
xraytech said:
But that was years ago. The 3rd party stuff may be better now.
Click to expand...

I got an EH-Band one and it was a bit loose and felt like it was going to come away from the watch, I’ve bought a genuine Apple one, it feels so much more secure.

Saying that I’ve had to get an exchange for it because it has a defect. Hopefully the replacement will be fine
 
coolbreeze2 said:
This add says these inexpensive Milanese loops are made of woven stainless steel. So does that mean they are a just as good as the Milanese loops Apple sells?
Click to expand...
OMG no! It means they're both made out of some type of steel, it speaks nothing to the quality of the steel or the craftsmanship that went into making it or whether the design fits properly with the watch.

To turn your question around, the cheapest Android phone has a flat, rounded rectangular case and a glass front, just like an iPhone - does that mean it is just as good as the phones that Apple sells?

The connectors on the non-Apple one that xraytech posted look positively hideous.

I have a Spigen-branded knockoff of the Milanese loop, in space gray (from back when Apple only had the shiny silver Milanese loop), that I got off Amazon for around $20. The connectors and craftsmanship are pretty good. If you search this forum for "Spigen" you'll see lots of positive comments about them.
 
Another thing, look how snug and perfect the lugs on the Apple loop fit in the watch compared with how loose the third party one looks, my 3rd party one hung out so much I could see the black springy bits.
 
OK I better buy from Apple. You all scared me away form the cheap ones.
 
You aren’t going to find anywhere close to the same quality in a knockoff band.
 
nieks said:
So much BS in this post. Please enlighten me: how is my knockoff band not on par with Apple standards? You just have to buy the right one.

t55oAzG.jpg


RYKl7c7.jpg


yXZPYhb.jpg
Click to expand...

I have a black milanese knock off and noticed the band does not completely fill the space where it sits on the bottom lug. It looks like yours also has this defect. The Apple milanese completely fills that space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarlJ
Yep, your band doesn’t fill the space like the real deal (in either direction) and looks bad to me.

Also the sides of the band aren’t flat on yours it looks like. I am not going to count but I suspect you don’t have as many rows, knockoffs tend to look chunky.

I can’t say on yours but the other knockoffs I have seen are quite a bit lighter and less substantial.

I have yet to see a fake one with as good a magnet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarlJ
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back