Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mmoin

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jun 15, 2001
138
0
Hi guys, just wondering what you think the best OS X browser is. For me, it would be Safari, if not for the caching and EBay problems, or Firebird, if auto-complete actually worked. What about you guys?
 
i use safari because it feels the fastest to me.

a few drawbacks i note:
  • cache problems ... especially on macrumors
  • Autofill is not perfect, but better than some
  • stop button is not responsive till steps later, often making the page reload
  • when loading a page in one tab and then trying to switch to another, often it will not switch until the page is loaded.
 
i like Safari best but there are a few annoyances that force me to use IE from time to time. say you are on a page with a huge list of text links like Amazon or a porn site and you click a link. once you're done with the page you press the back button or Cmnd+[. Safari wants to take you back to the exact point in the page where you were. this is a great feature but sometimes it takes way to long and screws things up. either perfect this feature or get rid of it. caching sucks as well. it also has lots of problems logging into and out of sites, like friendster for example. the stop button can be annoying and unresponsive causing you to click it more than once and then it just ends up reloading the page a million times. other than that Safari is awesome and feels much faster than anything out there. as for the caching thing, i've created an AppleScript that automatically deletes the cache folder everytime i do anything in Safari. it runs in the background and has helped alot.
 
safari has the best integration with the os (this kind of goes without saying). i've turned off disk cache for all of my browsers (safari, chimera, mozilla 1.5a). on my broadband connection, safari seems to be slightly faster than nightlies of chimera, but on dial-up, chimera seems a tiny bit faster than safari in most cases. i've only tried moz1.5 on my dial-up but it's the fastest of them all - really fast.

ad blocking is the one issue that really hurts. i like safari the best at the moment, but moz/chim come with built-in ad-blocking. pithhelmet seriously slows down safari so i no longer use it. you can block ads by applying a custom stylesheet to safari, but it never seems to work for more than one site.

if you only want a browser, i'd stick with safari and try to get a decent ad-blocker css sheet (keep in mind that chimera .8 will probably change my opinion :) ).

moz 1.5 is the fastest and you can use cool xul add-ons like www.xulchannels.com, but for day-to-day use, it's safari followed (and sometimes surpassed) by chimera.
 
I like Safari. I don't have the problems many people are reporting. It can be sketchy with my online banking (1/3 of the time works 1/3 of the time displays properly after repeated reloads 1/3 of the time it beachballs and crashes). I had to use IE when I did my taxes (quicken on Yahoo)--but those are my only problems. Ebay works fine for me, by the way.
 
Originally posted by mnkeybsness

[*]stop button is not responsive till steps later, often making the page reload

[/list]

That has got to be one of the biggest annoyances for me with Safari. That and the fact that it has been crashing more frequently with version 1.0. I still like it the best because I have been able to manage my bookmarks better than in other browsers.
 
Originally posted by Daveman Deluxe
I think Safari is great. I actually don't have any problems with eBay. How strange.

I am the same. I don't have the problems that are always spoken about around here with Ebay. I must be one of the lucky ones because I use Ebay all the time.

Safari just feels the fastest to me. Every now and then I'll have to open up IE to make something work, but that's rarely.
 
Safari for me. i think it's because i used to use IE and i needed somethign better, so i went with safari once the public beta was out.
 
Safari become my full time browser once it started to work with my online banking site. Since I visit a fairly limited number of websites I don;t have much of a problem in running into sites that Safari doesn't work on.
 
I love Safari, the only problem is accessing some secure sites, mainly my Car Insurance, Both of my Banks, and Verizon. Other than that I've had no problems. And to those of you having problems accessing eBay, try resetting the browser. I did it by accident, and suddenly eBay worked right, Hotmail worked, and pages loaded faster.

Overall:
Safari
Mozilla (1.4) - Needs to opperate faster, the speed is horrid
IE - Hate it, but it is faster than Mozilla

TEG
 
Originally posted by jbomber
what problem is there with using safari on ebay? i haven't noticed anything weird.

uploading pictures. It just won't work. Everything else is fine.

Safari also doesn't work on several database pages on my school's website, so I have to use IE to do a lot of research...
 
Really pleased so far

Originally posted by KCK
Safari become my full time browser once it started to work with my online banking site. Since I visit a fairly limited number of websites I don;t have much of a problem in running into sites that Safari doesn't work on.

I love Safari for it's silky smooth speed at page rendering, although the first site you browse to takes a while to load, for some reason.

Some Java applets seem to freeze Safari for a while, as well. Annoying IE on the PC seems to have no problem. And I though MS had meddled with the JVM?

I just wish Safari was a little more forgiving with bad HTML and javascripts, namely, my own :D

MARK

Edit:
Oh the irony... I clicked Submit to post the above and Safari 'unexpectantly quit'!! Still got thru though, phew!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.