Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

BigdaddyMBP

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 19, 2008
30
0
NYC
No gaming, just Media Server, and ripping DVD's / constantly. Also would be connected to HD TV for 1080p playback so it needs to be able to perform graphically when playing back content.

From a performance perspective which is the best bet?

No Gaming
No Major Photo Editing
No Movie making etc
 
Upgrade to i7 if you want helps with processing it faster.

8Gb of ram. From my experience it seems to eat a lot of ram. So having 8 would have with headroom.
 
Fastest Handbrake rips will be with the quad core server model, but none of them are bad choices.

To put it in perspective, the base model mini is essentially the same as the 13" base model MacBook Pro. On my 13" MBP I can rip an average length movie in about 35-40 minutes.

On my quad core mini server, it takes about 20-25 minutes.

Whether that is worth another $350 (because you absolutely must add RAM to the base model) is up to you.

If you're going to be ripping DVD's constantly, then you probably have a large collection to go through and the speed will be worthwhile. Having the two, faster, 500GB hard drives built in already is also helpful for a media server.

It will also be helpful for future use, as at some point you may decide to use an external Blu Ray drive and rip from those. Converting those files in Handbrake will be more time consuming than standard DVD's, and you'll be thankful for the speed boost if you ever decide to do that.

For your purposes, you will want to pick between the base model or the server model. The $799 one with the GPU may be good for gamers, but it will be useless for your needs, and the processor isn't going to be noticeably faster.
 
if people aren't ripping blue ray , then why bother? Even then, how many times will you watch the films?

You clearly don't have young children. :D I have over 50 kid's movies ripped/encoded and I'd bet each has been watched well into double digits.
 
No gaming, just Media Server, and ripping DVD's / constantly. Also would be connected to HD TV for 1080p playback so it needs to be able to perform graphically when playing back content.

From a performance perspective which is the best bet?

No Gaming
No Major Photo Editing
No Movie making etc

I use my new Mini the same way and I have the base model ($599) with 8GB RAM upgrade, working just fine.
 
Are you going to use it as "media Server" or as HTPC?

If the first I would suggest a Synology Nas, which is cheaper and in some ways more versatile.
if the second: yes, I fully recommend a mac Mini (and would still strongly advice to add a cheap Nas!)
 
It is really quite ironic that so many people use the Mac Mini as a media server and RIP DVD's on it, but Apple chose to take out the Optical drive. I bought my Mini in 2010 and use it with two USB Toshiba Canvio 1Tb drives. Movies on one and TV shows on the other. Don't see myself considering an upgrade anytime soon. I run Plex to manage the content.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.