Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
After finally renewing my Pixel 8 Pro for the Pixel 9 Pro XL, I'd like to do a review of the cameras on my three mobile devices that I currently own. The photographs are all taken at 50MP or, failing that, at the maximum resolution they can offer.

The order of the photos is as follows: iPhone 15 PM, Google Pixel 9 Pro XL, Samsung Galaxy Fold 6.

In the first picture, we note that the white balance of the Samsung and the iPhone is quite similar, while on the Pixel it is somewhat warmer and with a more “violet” tone. At first glance all photos offer a fairly good quality, with a very similar work of the lights, good in all three models.

54030010104_e8e3662a0e_b.jpg

54029928208_bb70e3bf71_b.jpg

54029678671_09d2a23eef_b.jpg


In terms of detail, the Pixel beats its rivals. If we look at the area of the flag and the signs, the Pixel is the only one where we can read what the sign says with more or less clarity, while on the iPhone it is quite difficult to see what it says. The worst of all is the Samsung, which makes a watercolor effect quite evident. It also makes some weird artifacts around the pole.

54030253050_2f610623ae_b.jpg

54030050883_48aa4bffc7_b.jpg

54029799461_e8e218c516_b.jpg


The second photo is at 5X. For obvious reasons, the Samsung is the worst (it only has 3X zoom, so the 5X zoom is done digitally). No doubt the photo is pretty bad.

54029679211_f14a72f042_b.jpg

54030011644_85bd1bb23b_b.jpg

54030011954_6510e99ecd_b.jpg


In the other two phones, we see a good job. For my taste, the iPhone contrasts the image too much, while the Pixel does a very good job. The Pixel's level of detail is excellent, better than Apple's. If we enlarge the photo a lot, on the Pixel we can see more than decently the car parked next to the church (a Dacia Spring from Carsharing). On the iPhone the car looks more pixelated.

54030252800_7ab098b20d_b.jpg

54028921307_7008f98a72_b.jpg


The third photo is also at 5X. The Samsung is again the worst, although this photo doesn't look as bad to me as the previous one.

54030133675_757ba5517c_b.jpg

54029681646_a97656c57a_b.jpg

54029931203_6634898cf4_b.jpg


Again we find an excess of contrast on the iPhone. At the level of detail, the Pixel again beats them all. If we enlarge the photo, the person lying on the beach and the waves are much clearer than on the iPhone. The Samsung does a fairly obvious watercolor.

54029799906_a811efcd7f_b.jpg

54028921812_9a0cf489bc_b.jpg

54028921422_b0ee5e15f9_b.jpg


The next photo, shot at 1X, shows the good HDR work of all three models, although I think the best in this regard is the Galaxy Fold. The Samsung and iPhone have a more similar white balance, being warmer. The Pixel makes the scene slightly cooler. The iPhone contrasts the scene a lot, especially in the area of the rocks. The Samsung in the corners makes a rather strange blurry effect (it does it also in other shots).

54030013899_5e6f53a0a8_b.jpg

54030135710_b95ba2501b_b.jpg

54029683201_a193115dde_b.jpg


In terms of detail, the Pixel again beats everyone.

The last scene, also at 1X. The iPhone takes a warmer scene than the other two phones. In this case, the HDR I think does a better job on the iPhone because it's able to pull more information out of the sky.

54030136320_8ec8eba0c5_b.jpg

54028804307_64853a8a59_b.jpg

54028804572_d86577f1d1_b.jpg


The Pixel's detail is still unsurpassed, with the Samsung being the worst again.

54028921777_0529b3651d_b.jpg

54030253505_02e835e96b_b.jpg

54029800081_d72bebf4a4_b.jpg


So, the Pixel is still the king of photography, at least of these three phones that I have. I still find it to be the best camera phone overall.

The performance of the Pixel 9 Pro XL I notice it noticeably better than the 8, something that surprised me, since I thought the processor was not noticeably better than last year.

When you shoot at 50MP, it doesn't take as long to take the photo, and the shutter time is much faster than on the 8 Pro, as well as the processing time.

The speakers have also improved quite a bit. The phone is more pleasant to hold in the hand, it seems better balanced to me. The screen looks better, and the fingerprint sensor is noticeably better.

The iPhone is still my primary personal device, while the Galaxy Fold is my professional device. The Pixel I like to have as a second phone, but each iteration (I've had the 7 Pro, 8 pro and, now, the 9 Pro XL) I notice there are noticeable improvements. I really like the AI features (although we don't have all of them available in Europe).

I like the Samsung for its productivity-related features. One UI has a thousand interesting functions, which help me in my day to day work.

The iPhone... well, it's the device I've relied on since 2009. With its pluses and minuses, in the end it is the backbone of my ecosystem, so for the time being it will remain so, because even if it doesn't have a camera as good as the Pixel (both the 8 Pro and 9 Pro XL have better cameras), it is much better than the 13 Pro Max I had before, being pretty solid in all situations.

I leave some pictures I took yesterday with the Pixel 9 Pro XL. (Unedited).
54030158489_7bd3c6ab79_b.jpg

54030158894_656bc95860_b.jpg

54030077543_279acdbfbf_b.jpg

54028948922_7088cc1006_b.jpg

54029827186_b0b059f710_b.jpg

54030280335_4045f6de8b_b.jpg

54028949537_23871a41fc_b.jpg

54029827641_af03052a3d_b.jpg

54030159294_b4cf3bfa6c_b.jpg

54028949377_5bf1a4df1f_b.jpg

54028949387_cf5832fdf7_b.jpg

54029828061_fbf90be2cb_b.jpg
 

User #07242024

macrumors regular
Jul 23, 2024
166
73
Wonder how iPhone 15 Pro Max’s photos would look like without heavy post processing such as using Halide or Neural Cam; or with the help of super resolution camera apps like Hydra or Cortex Cam…
 

jamezr

macrumors P6
Aug 7, 2011
16,072
19,066
US
After finally renewing my Pixel 8 Pro for the Pixel 9 Pro XL, I'd like to do a review of the cameras on my three mobile devices that I currently own. The photographs are all taken at 50MP or, failing that, at the maximum resolution they can offer.

The order of the photos is as follows: iPhone 15 PM, Google Pixel 9 Pro XL, Samsung Galaxy Fold 6.

In the first picture, we note that the white balance of the Samsung and the iPhone is quite similar, while on the Pixel it is somewhat warmer and with a more “violet” tone. At first glance all photos offer a fairly good quality, with a very similar work of the lights, good in all three models.

54030010104_e8e3662a0e_b.jpg

54029928208_bb70e3bf71_b.jpg

54029678671_09d2a23eef_b.jpg


In terms of detail, the Pixel beats its rivals. If we look at the area of the flag and the signs, the Pixel is the only one where we can read what the sign says with more or less clarity, while on the iPhone it is quite difficult to see what it says. The worst of all is the Samsung, which makes a watercolor effect quite evident. It also makes some weird artifacts around the pole.

54030253050_2f610623ae_b.jpg

54030050883_48aa4bffc7_b.jpg

54029799461_e8e218c516_b.jpg


The second photo is at 5X. For obvious reasons, the Samsung is the worst (it only has 3X zoom, so the 5X zoom is done digitally). No doubt the photo is pretty bad.

54029679211_f14a72f042_b.jpg

54030011644_85bd1bb23b_b.jpg

54030011954_6510e99ecd_b.jpg


In the other two phones, we see a good job. For my taste, the iPhone contrasts the image too much, while the Pixel does a very good job. The Pixel's level of detail is excellent, better than Apple's. If we enlarge the photo a lot, on the Pixel we can see more than decently the car parked next to the church (a Dacia Spring from Carsharing). On the iPhone the car looks more pixelated.

54030252800_7ab098b20d_b.jpg

54028921307_7008f98a72_b.jpg


The third photo is also at 5X. The Samsung is again the worst, although this photo doesn't look as bad to me as the previous one.

54030133675_757ba5517c_b.jpg

54029681646_a97656c57a_b.jpg

54029931203_6634898cf4_b.jpg


Again we find an excess of contrast on the iPhone. At the level of detail, the Pixel again beats them all. If we enlarge the photo, the person lying on the beach and the waves are much clearer than on the iPhone. The Samsung does a fairly obvious watercolor.

54029799906_a811efcd7f_b.jpg

54028921812_9a0cf489bc_b.jpg

54028921422_b0ee5e15f9_b.jpg


The next photo, shot at 1X, shows the good HDR work of all three models, although I think the best in this regard is the Galaxy Fold. The Samsung and iPhone have a more similar white balance, being warmer. The Pixel makes the scene slightly cooler. The iPhone contrasts the scene a lot, especially in the area of the rocks. The Samsung in the corners makes a rather strange blurry effect (it does it also in other shots).

54030013899_5e6f53a0a8_b.jpg

54030135710_b95ba2501b_b.jpg

54029683201_a193115dde_b.jpg


In terms of detail, the Pixel again beats everyone.

The last scene, also at 1X. The iPhone takes a warmer scene than the other two phones. In this case, the HDR I think does a better job on the iPhone because it's able to pull more information out of the sky.

54030136320_8ec8eba0c5_b.jpg

54028804307_64853a8a59_b.jpg

54028804572_d86577f1d1_b.jpg


The Pixel's detail is still unsurpassed, with the Samsung being the worst again.

54028921777_0529b3651d_b.jpg

54030253505_02e835e96b_b.jpg

54029800081_d72bebf4a4_b.jpg


So, the Pixel is still the king of photography, at least of these three phones that I have. I still find it to be the best camera phone overall.

The performance of the Pixel 9 Pro XL I notice it noticeably better than the 8, something that surprised me, since I thought the processor was not noticeably better than last year.

When you shoot at 50MP, it doesn't take as long to take the photo, and the shutter time is much faster than on the 8 Pro, as well as the processing time.

The speakers have also improved quite a bit. The phone is more pleasant to hold in the hand, it seems better balanced to me. The screen looks better, and the fingerprint sensor is noticeably better.

The iPhone is still my primary personal device, while the Galaxy Fold is my professional device. The Pixel I like to have as a second phone, but each iteration (I've had the 7 Pro, 8 pro and, now, the 9 Pro XL) I notice there are noticeable improvements. I really like the AI features (although we don't have all of them available in Europe).

I like the Samsung for its productivity-related features. One UI has a thousand interesting functions, which help me in my day to day work.

The iPhone... well, it's the device I've relied on since 2009. With its pluses and minuses, in the end it is the backbone of my ecosystem, so for the time being it will remain so, because even if it doesn't have a camera as good as the Pixel (both the 8 Pro and 9 Pro XL have better cameras), it is much better than the 13 Pro Max I had before, being pretty solid in all situations.

I leave some pictures I took yesterday with the Pixel 9 Pro XL. (Unedited).
54030158489_7bd3c6ab79_b.jpg

54030158894_656bc95860_b.jpg

54030077543_279acdbfbf_b.jpg

54028948922_7088cc1006_b.jpg

54029827186_b0b059f710_b.jpg

54030280335_4045f6de8b_b.jpg

54028949537_23871a41fc_b.jpg

54029827641_af03052a3d_b.jpg

54030159294_b4cf3bfa6c_b.jpg

54028949377_5bf1a4df1f_b.jpg

54028949387_cf5832fdf7_b.jpg

54029828061_fbf90be2cb_b.jpg
Thank you for doing all of that! It took a lot of effort and work. It looks like the Fold comes in last most of the time against the iPhone 15 and Pixel 9 XL and both of those have better cameras than the Fold 6. I wonder how it go to compare the Galaxy 24 Ultra?
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
Thank you for doing all of that! It took a lot of effort and work. It looks like the Fold comes in last most of the time against the iPhone 15 and Pixel 9 XL and both of those have better cameras than the Fold 6. I wonder how it go to compare the Galaxy 24 Ultra?
A few months ago I was able to compare the Pixel 8 Pro with the S24U and they were more or less even, although in zoom the Samsung obviously won.

The Samsung tended to display very aggressive HDR making sometimes strange artifacts, and the sharpness and definition of objects was somewhat worse than on the Pixel.

Samsung S24U vs Pixel 8 Pro

53515426203_f477725f6c_b.jpg

53514372637_c171d4c91f_b.jpg

53514378392_45b9a560eb_b.jpg

53514378167_816da16eea_b.jpg
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.