Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

lemon^

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Mar 2, 2008
7
0
And my Macbook Air just did the screeching sound again. Second time in 2 days. I'm starting to think I should take it in.
 

e12a

macrumors 68000
Oct 28, 2006
1,881
0
looks like these tiny wonder drives have a short MTBF.
 

NC MacGuy

macrumors 603
Feb 9, 2005
6,233
0
The good side of the grass.
Mine did it too yesterday. I'm not convinced it was the drive though. Sounded like the speaker. Immediately checked console log and nothing showed and worked normally during and after.... Still glad I'm using time machine.
 

cohibadad

macrumors 6502a
Jul 21, 2007
893
5
sounds like the speaker. it's probably one of those things you tell the Apple guy about then you go to reproduce it and wait, wait, wait...nothing. Then you go home and it does it immediately.
 

NC MacGuy

macrumors 603
Feb 9, 2005
6,233
0
The good side of the grass.
sounds like the speaker. it's probably one of those things you tell the Apple guy about then you go to reproduce it and wait, wait, wait...nothing. Then you go home and it does it immediately.

Exactly. I'm thinking maybe the new Intel sound proc. they used w. mono speaker setup. It really didn't sound like a hard drive to me when I heard mine do it. More like one of the funky "something's seriously wrong" alert beeps. Like I said, mine worked fine during and after w. nothing on system log. Weird.
 

sparkstack

Guest
Feb 19, 2008
36
0
Grrr.

I received my replacement air yesterday. No screws have fell out of this one so far, but it did make the screeching noise, for about 30 seconds when i first turned it on.

It is most definitely NOT the hard drive. The noise is coming from the speaker. Next time it does it. stick your ear on the keyboard near the enter key, listen for a while and then stick you head on the underside of the machine in the same kinda place. On the keyboard side you will just hear the speaker making the screeching / popping / scratching noise. On the back side, you here the same noise, muted, and you can very quietly hear the HD spinning, seeking, doing what it normally does.

It hasn't done it since, and i used it for about 6 hours last night, restoring my time machine image from the old machine and working on some files.
 

NC MacGuy

macrumors 603
Feb 9, 2005
6,233
0
The good side of the grass.
Grrr.

I received my replacement air yesterday. No screws have fell out of this one so far, but it did make the screeching noise, for about 30 seconds when i first turned it on.

It is most definitely NOT the hard drive. The noise is coming from the speaker. Next time it does it. stick your ear on the keyboard near the enter key, listen for a while and then stick you head on the underside of the machine in the same kinda place. On the keyboard side you will just hear the speaker making the screeching / popping / scratching noise. On the back side, you here the same noise, muted, and you can very quietly hear the HD spinning, seeking, doing what it normally does.

It hasn't done it since, and i used it for about 6 hours last night, restoring my time machine image from the old machine and working on some files.

Hopefully #2 is a winner!

I totally agree w. speaker noise vs. HD for screeching. It really almost sounds like some sort of warning tone to me.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.