I use Paranoid Android, but it's Nexi only.
I don't bother with customs anymore I just root and use xposed.
Stock rooted. Waiting for xposed to support art before playing with xposed.
Another Xposed user here. I get essentially all of the features I enjoyed in custom ROMs via GravityBox and other modules, without having to wait for devs when a new build of Android is released.
You guys don't mention what devices are you using. You mean stock AOSP rom or stock software from your manufacturer (Sense, TouchWiz, etc)?
I've been over a week now with Vanir rom on my SGS3. Last week's I've been trying 20 different roms trying to find the one I needed until I found this one and it's perfect.
Turned off the capacitive buttons and enabled the nav bar with the ring and one target for screenshots.
Installed also Gravity Box.
Basically just turned my SGS3 into a Nexus 5 almost.
You won't believe how much faster and fluid my phone is now.
Now I'm looking for themes for the new CM11S theme engine.
OP, there are way way more roms better than CM. To me CM is old news. They don't even allow to disable completely the capacitive buttons if you use the nav bar (which I also think is not included in CM) I think or just the menu one. Don't remember exactly.
I would recommend Temasek rom for the SGS3.