Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ReallyBigFeet

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Apr 15, 2010
2,956
133
Dislikes outweigh likes right now....

-Not a fan of folio keyboard. You flip it back to use it as a tablet and your hand is pressing all these buttons. Not a deal breaker but def weird relative to the grippy suede of the old keyboard cover. Also, you can’t put a back on this like you could with old keyboard. So no real way around this unless you just go naked.
-Using it naked, or in landscape tablet mode at all, and you’ll almost certainly find Face ID totally blocked as your palm/hand is covering the camera. Face ID will tell you this, but it basically means unless you are natively left handed (and thus holding it in your right hand) you’ll have to flip this thing around every time you use it in tablet mode. And if you flip this around, the Apple Pencil is now on the bottom if attached, meaning it’s almost certainly going to have to come off.
-Charger loses the Apple aesthetics and now it’s just a big iPhone brick
-The magnet for the pencil is pretty weak. It’s ended up on the floor multiple times already.
-This is a chunky slap of metal. Sort of like holding a Surface tablet now (which I also have). No curved baby’s bottom. Just all edges and flat metal now.

Likes.....
-Noticeably faster
-Noticeably better battery performance, but that may not be fair as my 2017 iPad Pro is 18 months old
-Screen just a tad bit warmer IMO but this is obviously subjective
-I’m kind of digging the USB-C design. I’ve connected several USB-C devices I had purchased for my MacBook and thus far everything appears to be working the same. IOS is pretty stupid about what it can/can’t do with some of the stuff I’ve connected to it, but they do work and gives me a few fewer things to dump into my gadget bag in my briefcase.
-More specific to the Pencil, YAY TO REMOVAL OF THAT BRITTLE STUPID PLASTIC CAP! I broke TWO of those almost within a few days of getting my first Pencil. The gestures on this one are kind of nifty also, but again...more of a Pencil like than an iPad Like.
 
You’re finding the Pencil magnet weak? That’s surprising; I find mine very strong and it secures the Pencil pretty solidly. The best test so far has been that it stays connected in my backpack; the Pen for my SP4 always fell off under the slightest pressure and would invariably end up at the bottom of my backpack.

I am impressed that you pay attention to charger aesthetics; I did’t look twice at it.
 
The only thing I am finding annoying is the Face ID is blocked by my had when using it in landscape. I mostly use that view. I'm sure I'll get adjusted to moving my had around though. It's fairly light, but compared to my iPad mini2 seems much larger and heavier. I'm glad I went for the 11" one. I think the 12.9 would be overkill for a device that I like to use to read with. I really love the larger screen and find it much easier to read since everything is bigger.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.