Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jsx97

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 6, 2022
31
7
Is there a drawing app with no undo? To not possible to undo any changes is the key feature I'm looking for.

Drawing apps are typically created for iPad, but for reasons that I don't think are interesting to listen about, I need this app to work on Mac as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heretiq

Big Bad D

macrumors 6502a
Jan 3, 2007
533
570
France
Good luck in your search and personal need, but I think your request is so outside of typical and basic functionality expectation that there's unlikely to be such an app.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tagbert

Slartibart

macrumors 68040
Aug 19, 2020
3,142
2,817
Many programs allow for setting e.g. the undo level and memory assigned to undo, e.g. here: Gimp settings. I suggest to check wether you can set the level or assigned memory to ”0”.
 

heretiq

Contributor
Jan 31, 2014
1,020
1,654
Denver, CO
@jsx97: If you are willing to try an iPad only app, you definitely owe it to yourself to give Exsto a try (https://apps.apple.com/us/app/exsto/id6444933770). It’s an unconventional vector drawing app with minimal controls and no undo by design. It’s a serious, very immersive drawing tool that was made for someone like you who is not afraid to eschew convention. Here are some examples of designs produced using Exsto (the dolphin is my own creation after 1 hour of playing with Exsto):

IMG_0473.jpeg


I don't think that is enough to get what you want. It makes no sense (to 99.99999%) on a drawing app in particular to have no way of undoing something.
@LeeW Try Exsto — a drawing app with no undo by design (https://exsto.app/) — and you might change your mind about the utility and sensibility of a drawing app with no undo. Apart from the OP’s legitimate desire to work around his OCD, having no undo actually enhances creativity and immersion while drawing with it.

Good luck in your search and personal need, but I think your request is so outside of typical and basic functionality expectation that there's unlikely to be such an app.

🙏🏽

I am curious, why not just have the discipline to not use the “undo” feature? Not trying to bring you down, but as a previous user said, having an app that has zero way to undo something is not something you are likely to find.
https://exsto.app/ 🙏🏽
 

Analog Kid

macrumors G3
Mar 4, 2003
9,360
12,602
I am curious, why not just have the discipline to not use the “undo” feature? Not trying to bring you down, but as a previous user said, having an app that has zero way to undo something is not something you are likely to find.
Can't speak for the OP, but based on what they've told us already I'd guess that the reason is specifically that lack of discipline. OCD gets used a lot of different ways in these forums but commonly it's a stand in for an inability to deal with imperfection. If that's the case here, I can see how it would be very hard to make progress on a drawing if one is constantly undoing and trying to refine the last stroke. If there's literally no way to back up, then the only way is forward.
 
Last edited:

Big Bad D

macrumors 6502a
Jan 3, 2007
533
570
France
Can't speak for the OP, but based on what they've told us already I'd guess that the reason is specifically that lack of discipline. OCD gets used a lot of different ways in these forums but commonly it's a stand in for an inability or unwillingness to deal with imperfection. If that's the case here, I can see how it would be very hard to make progress on a drawing if one is constantly undoing and trying to refine the last stroke. If there's literally no way to back up, then the only way is forward.
Thanks for sharing that potential explanation. I was struggling to comprehend but interested to better be aware how OCD and undo feature might be impacted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tagbert and heretiq

hishnash

macrumors newbie
May 24, 2017
22
6
You’re welcome @jsx97. I don’t know if a Mac version is planned, but hopefully you can try it on an iPad.
Hi, I am one of the devs on the team (of 2) behind Exsto.

Yes we do plan on adding Mac support but doing this properly (so that the ux is smooth and responsive) is a big challenge, we did just ship a big update to Exsto 2.0 (of iPad only still) also launched on Product Hunt: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/exsto

The update focuses even more on the creative flow, with a few key changes.

1) Each new canvas starts out with a randomly selected (from a crafted collection) color set so that you can start creating without fiddling around finding the color you like.

2) Brand new Metal backend that provides much more responsive panning and zooming (after all the canvas is infinite and I have creations with well over 50k strokes)

3) A short on-boarding tutorial just to get users used to the strokes and how different it is to other apps

4) Apple Pencil pressure and tilt now subtly influence the `noise` level of the brush, this is intentionally very subtle, the lighter you touch the streen the more noise and the more inclined the angle of the pencil to the screen the more noise. and of course the inverse, the more pressure the less noise on that part of the stroke and if you have the pencil perpendicular to the screen that is also less noise. We found with these changes I can in most cases avoid needing to adjust the noise setting while creating.

We aslo cleaned up what UI a lot thanks to some great feedback we got from sessions with apples app design team.
 

heretiq

Contributor
Jan 31, 2014
1,020
1,654
Denver, CO
Hi, I am one of the devs on the team (of 2) behind Exsto.

Yes we do plan on adding Mac support but doing this properly (so that the ux is smooth and responsive) is a big challenge, we did just ship a big update to Exsto 2.0 (of iPad only still) also launched on Product Hunt: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/exsto

The update focuses even more on the creative flow, with a few key changes.

1) Each new canvas starts out with a randomly selected (from a crafted collection) color set so that you can start creating without fiddling around finding the color you like.

2) Brand new Metal backend that provides much more responsive panning and zooming (after all the canvas is infinite and I have creations with well over 50k strokes)

3) A short on-boarding tutorial just to get users used to the strokes and how different it is to other apps

4) Apple Pencil pressure and tilt now subtly influence the `noise` level of the brush, this is intentionally very subtle, the lighter you touch the streen the more noise and the more inclined the angle of the pencil to the screen the more noise. and of course the inverse, the more pressure the less noise on that part of the stroke and if you have the pencil perpendicular to the screen that is also less noise. We found with these changes I can in most cases avoid needing to adjust the noise setting while creating.

We aslo cleaned up what UI a lot thanks to some great feedback we got from sessions with apples app design team.
Thanks for the update @hishnash and thanks to the Exsto team for providing such an inspired app! 🙏🏽

Good luck! This app deserves to exist and deserves to be discovered by every iPad creative and aspiring creative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hishnash

chrono1081

macrumors G3
Jan 26, 2008
8,720
5,182
Isla Nublar
Thanks for sharing that potential explanation. I was struggling to comprehend but interested to better be aware how OCD and undo feature might be impacted.

It could be OCD or OCPD (which people confuse with OCD, OCPD is where people are a perfectionist/super organized).

As someone who used to suffer from legit OCD it could be his trigger. It could be something like "for every pen stroke I have to hit undo twice or everyone I love will die". (OCD is utterly stupid like that and you know it's stupid but you can't help but give in to whatever ritual it is).

For me mine was anything with an on/off, up/down or open/close state. I had to turn lights off "correctly" or repeat it a million times until it felt correct. Same with opening/closing doors. Then on the TV I could only turn the channel up, never down even if it meant cycling through hundreds of channels.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.