Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

verdejt

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jul 19, 2011
363
110
Central Florida
Just a quick question. I have a 2010 MacPro and it’s missing 2 drive drive sleds. I’m looking for 2 replacements. My question is will any year drive sled work or do I need to stick to the 2009-2012 versions.
 
Thanks. I know the enclosure has had subtle changes over the years but wasn’t sure what changed.
2006/2007 are the same enclosure, 2008 is a little larger and have different logic board standoffs, bigger heatsinks, but same sleds. 2009/2010/2012 are the exact same enclosure again.

2008 is the only year that have a unique enclosure.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bookemdano
I know I just bashed on OWC in another thread, but if you need to buy cMP 2009/10/12 sleds and aren't picky about them having the silkscreened numbers on them, then you may strongly want to consider purchasing the OWC sleds for only a few bucks more than buying used genuine sleds on ebay:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00L1DH3AA

The OWC ones have the correct screw pattern to accommodate today's higher capacity 6TB+ drives whereas the genuine Apple sleds don't.

Or, if you're going to be throwing an SSD on them anyway, you could buy the OWC SSD sleds for only $17.50 each:

https://www.adorama.com/owcmmp35t25.html

Not sure why OWC made them blue, but I guess in a good way it makes it easy to discern what bay your SSDs are in.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
if you're feeling adventurous, you can download the 3D printing software to your laptop plus the reenforced plastic template and print one at your local library. It takes about 50 - 70 minutes to print one though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chung123 and ekwipt
if you're feeling adventurous, you can download the 3D printing software to your laptop plus the reenforced plastic template and print one at your local library. It takes about 50 - 70 minutes to print one though.

Wow, you can do this at a public library? I had no idea...

What 3D printing software are you referring to, and where do you download the template?

I’d like to do this myself just for the fun.
 
the template would be very handy. At my school there is a design department that uses a 3d printer to do lots of stuff.
 
Pretty good. I have Mojave running on the SSD and I have installed a second hard drive that I use just for data like documents and pictures and downloads just to keep as much as I can off the SSD since it's only a 250gb. The only complaint I have is in Safari when going to certain pages such as Facebook I get a spinning ball for about 3 seconds then I can access the page normally. It's only certain pages like I said and I attribute this more to Mojave than the machine itself. My wife starts back to school in a couple of weeks and that's when I will really get to push it doing data tracking spreadsheets and desktop publishing for her class. She teaches 6th grade science. I have noticed that the SSD has about 59% life left. So in the near future I'm going to be replacing it with something newer. On a side note it was damaged in shipping and I have a claim in with FEDEX for a new/used case. Can't hurt worst they will say is no and I will have to pick one up a little later on. It is way faster then the 2009 core2duo iMac I was using. Downside I need to purchase another monitor to have my 2 monitor setup back or get one big monitor. I was wondering if you had any experience using say a 40" or so HDTV. I'm only interested in 1080p right now and have no plans for 4K until it's more mainstream. The TV route is waaaay cheaper than a computer monitor the same size.
 
I have noticed that the SSD has about 59% life left. So in the near future I'm going to be replacing it with something newer. .

Is that 59% life left or space left? I'm running 1TB SSDs in my 2010 MP 5,1, from both Crucial and OWC, using OWC sleds. Also running a couple other Macs with Crucial SSDs. The Crucial SSDs are a little less expensive than the ones from OWC, but still high quality.
 
Pretty good. I have Mojave running on the SSD and I have installed a second hard drive that I use just for data like documents and pictures and downloads just to keep as much as I can off the SSD since it's only a 250gb. The only complaint I have is in Safari when going to certain pages such as Facebook I get a spinning ball for about 3 seconds then I can access the page normally. It's only certain pages like I said and I attribute this more to Mojave than the machine itself. My wife starts back to school in a couple of weeks and that's when I will really get to push it doing data tracking spreadsheets and desktop publishing for her class. She teaches 6th grade science. I have noticed that the SSD has about 59% life left. So in the near future I'm going to be replacing it with something newer. On a side note it was damaged in shipping and I have a claim in with FEDEX for a new/used case. Can't hurt worst they will say is no and I will have to pick one up a little later on. It is way faster then the 2009 core2duo iMac I was using. Downside I need to purchase another monitor to have my 2 monitor setup back or get one big monitor. I was wondering if you had any experience using say a 40" or so HDTV. I'm only interested in 1080p right now and have no plans for 4K until it's more mainstream. The TV route is waaaay cheaper than a computer monitor the same size.
I do not have any experience with TVs in place of a monitor. I only use monitors on my systems and the largest I have is my Apple 23" Cinema Display. When it comes to monitors I'm way behind the times.
 
I guess one way to test would be to run all of them on the same drive and see if they agree on the % life remaining.
 
Sorry for the late response. I had a personal appearance this weekend, so I was hella busy.

Repetier-host is the windows software to print the CAD items. I'm not sure if there's a Mac version, but since all modern apple laptops run Windows 7/10 it shouldn't be an issue.

Here are links to the CAD files for the sleds and adapters:
4,1/5,1 sled: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2759563
1,1/3,1 sled: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2771531
SSD adapter: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1630550
Those CAD files are for 60% fill, but Repetier-host can increase the fill to 100%.

Here's a partial video printing a drive sled:

Here are a few photos of printing in progress, and finished product:
31-sled-progress.jpg

31-sled-layout.jpg

ssd-adapt-finished.jpg

ssd-adapt-layout.jpg


Wow, you can do this at a public library? I had no idea...

What 3D printing software are you referring to, and where do you download the template?

I’d like to do this myself just for the fun.

the template would be very handy. At my school there is a design department that uses a 3d printer to do lots of stuff.
 
Last edited:
^^^^I use Hardware Monitor too, though development of the product has ceased, I do not see where it lists the life left of my drives. It lists the temps measured by the various sensors located in my mac.

Lou
 
What/where reports the remaining amount of life left?
^^^^I'd like to know this too.

Lou

You will need some software that can really show you all SMART data, not just the temperature. I still don't know any method in terminal to get them so far.

^^^^I use Hardware Monitor too, though development of the product has ceased, I do not see where it lists the life left of my drives. It lists the temps measured by the various sensors located in my mac.

Lou

It seems 10.13.6 block the SMART info extraction. May be some software is already updated to "fix" it. But I didn't follow closely in this area, so no idea which one can work.

However, if you have Windows / Linux, there should be lots of software that can read the SMART status. This is drive format independent. So, even your drives are format to APFS, Windows software can still read the SMART status.

e.g. My Samsung 1TB 840 Evo shows 97 TB Written.
magic.PNG


The TLC should be rated around 1000 cycle. So, I can expect a total of 1000 TB life span. And ~100 TB written means I still has ~90% life span left.

And if I click the S.M.A.R.T button below. I will see this
wear.PNG


Threshold is 0 (0% life span left), and my current value is 90. So, 90% life span left as per the prediction above.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.