His machine is NOT broken. All it has is a noise when he opens it up (caused from his own fault FFS), yet someone says that warrents Apple replacing his whole notepad. Grow up, get a life, and take some responsibilty for yourselves. Now if you would care to look I have already started a thread on dropping macbooks as i have done it myself... twice, however instead of posting and trying to scam Apple and their genuine customers out of money I admitted my stupidity and COMPLIMENTED APPLE ON THE ROBUSTNESS OF THEIR MACHINES because SHOCK HORROR it still works. But oh no shold I take it back and get it replaced at someone elses expense? Grow up FFS.
Blimey looks like ive touched a nerve. No offence, but if you want me to grow up, maybe you should look at youself first. Im not the one ***** and blinding.
Oh and by the way, please dont type whole sentences in capitals. Alot of people find it quite aggressive and rude.
Anyway, like I said, its a dog eat dog world. If you brought a car, and got a little knock on the side, you wouldnt really expect all the windows to shatter, and screws come loose in the engine, would you? I dropped my macbook a while ago on the way to get the top lid replaced because it went discoloured. It got a small dent in the corner, obviously got nothing to do with the discolouration at all. I got there, and they said I had mis-treated my macbook, and they wanted £120+ for a new top case, because apparently the warrenty was voided when I dropped it.
I took it to another apple repair place, and they told me how crap apple was in cases like this, and if there was a small scratch on it, they wouldnt replace anything. He said that he has been working as an apple repair man for over 20+ years, and he always hears the same story over and over, that apple wont replace something for this and that. So, if apple is screwing over all these people like that for petti things, then why shouldnt people try and get their monies worth. Apple are certainly seeing it that way.
My advice to you is to take it to a local apple service centre, and see if they will take the screen part off for you and see what it is rattling apart. It may just be a case of taking off the case, taking out whats rattling, and replace it again. If everything is working fine, then I cant see it being anything major.