Wouldn't this thread have to be moved, "if" it was in the console forum?
I don't know about these dedicated 5.1 headphones, or gaming headphones, but I use my Sennheiser HD 555s for late night gaming and they offer true surround sound. I can hear when someone is behind me, to to my left, etc. They have this thing they call a Surround reflector, which as noted really works.
They sound great with a headphone amp for music as well, which is why I bought them. They're very comfortable