After dealing with this problem several years ago, I thought it had been left far behind. But I recently got a new Toshiba 3TB HD and hooked it up to my server running High Sierra (SSD, 16 GB RAM, 2012) Did not look closely at what Disk Utility was doing, but chose to initialize it in APFS as one volume. When it was finished, it was an 801 GB HD. Have tried many things to get it back, but nothing works... How do I get the missing 2+ TBs back? All the old solutions dealing with the old 2TB limit do not work today.