Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Huge safari memory leak

ferdi2005

ferdi2005

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 13, 2018
9
0
After I updated to Big Sur, Safari is having an huge memory leak on my MacBook pro 16 ! I'm The system asked me to close it because RAM was ending. (showing an unrealistic 106 GB because I have only 16 GB of RAM, but it asked me to close it!). I tried to disable extensions but nothing changed and it's gaining more and more RAM. I just started it up and opened three tabs and it ate 3 GB of RAM!
Any ideas?


Schermata 2020-11-14 alle 16.51.49.png
 
I have been using internal betas of Safari 14 from Catalina and I have seen the same sorts of issues. Experimentally, I have found that disabling the stupid new "Start Page" feature goes a helps to correct the issue. After configuring the browser to open new tabs as blank pages, I am seeing lower memory usage.
 
Also having this issue. I completely quit Safari, browsed the internet for 2 hours and this is the memory usage after the 2 hours (it constantly climbed up):
C4541DD7-2593-49CB-ABB8-539D46B20A8B.png
Safari is using almost 20 GB even though I just have 8 GB of RAM. I think this is possible due to virtual RAM but Safari shouldn’t use this much RAM :(
 
Use option to launch Safari without extensions. Also try turning off apps that launch on startup / login.
 
Also happened to me. It's quite easy to reproduce on my side, simply open several google pages and close it, the memory will keep increasing. After some trials, it turns out to be related to the ad blocker extension - 1Blocker. When I disable it, the memory leak issue resolved.
 
EDIT: Oopsie, you were a bit faster ;)

Ok, here's what I found out. I THINK that the issue is the extension 1Blocker (unfortunately this probably isn't the solution for you since you tried to launch Safari without extensions but maybe it helps someone else). Here was my test procedure.

One note beforehand: To monitor the RAM usage I used iStat Menus. iStat Menus always gives me a way higher Safari memory usage compared to the Safari entry in the activity monitor. I think this is because iStat Menus shows multiple Safari entries combined (e. g. there are also entries called "Safari web content (in cache)" in the activity monitor).

1.) Completely quit Safari
2.) Launch Safari, watch heavy 4K/60 clip
3. [See Safari memory usage with iStat Menus]
4.) Go on some websites
5.) [See Safari memory usage]
6.) Quit Safari (but NOT completely, so just click the red X)
7.) [See Safari memory usage]

WITH 1Blocker X, after the video the usage was at around 2 GB, climbed to 2.5 while surfing on some websites and now the very interesting part: When I quit Safari with the red X the usage stayed about the same BUT: In the activity monitor Safari was listed with hundreds of MB (<-- I will come back to this fact later).

WITHOUT 1Blocker X, after the video the usage was at around 1 - 1.5 GB and stayed there while surfing on some websites and when I quit Safari with the red X the Safari entry itself showed just a usage of around 160 MB (+ some "Safari web content (in cache)" entries with a few hundred MB each.

So it seems like with 1Blocker the used RAM doesn't get freed somehow.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: volzkzg
So, for small periods me the difference is small with or without 1Blocker and other extensions: Safari continues to leak memory but it doesn't leak memory on a fresh user! If I use it for a longer period of time, with 1Blocker the memory leak situations explodes, without it, the memory usage remains exaggerate (way more than 1.5 GB) but it's less.

Thank you all really much for your help, let's remain in contact and understand how to fix.
chris4565 said:
EDIT: Oopsie, you were a bit faster ;)

Ok, here's what I found out. I THINK that the issue is the extension 1Blocker (unfortunately this probably isn't the solution for you since you tried to launch Safari without extensions but maybe it helps someone else). Here was my test procedure.

One note beforehand: To monitor the RAM usage I used iStat Menus. iStat Menus always gives me a way higher Safari memory usage compared to the Safari entry in the activity monitor. I think this is because iStat Menus shows multiple Safari entries combined (e. g. there are also entries called "Safari web content (in cache)" in the activity monitor).

1.) Completely quit Safari
2.) Launch Safari, watch heavy 4K/60 clip
3. [See Safari memory usage with iStat Menus]
4.) Go on some websites
5.) [See Safari memory usage]
6.) Quit Safari (but NOT completely, so just click the red X)
7.) [See Safari memory usage]

WITH 1Blocker X, after the video the usage was at around 2 GB, climbed to 2.5 while surfing on some websites and now the very interesting part: When I quit Safari with the red X the usage stayed about the same BUT: In the activity monitor Safari was listed with hundreds of MB (<-- I will come back to this fact later).

WITHOUT 1Blocker X, after the video the usage was at around 1 - 1.5 GB and stayed there while surfing on some websites and when I quit Safari with the red X the Safari entry itself showed just a usage of around 160 MB (+ some "Safari web content (in cache)" entries with a few hundred MB each.

So it seems like with 1Blocker the used RAM doesn't get freed somehow.
Click to expand...
 
ferdi2005 said:
Thank you all really much for your help, let's remain in contact and understand how to fix.
Click to expand...
Sure, just so you know: I contacted Alex from 1Blocker support and he's super nice and supportive. I've already contacted him for issues in the past and they have always been resolved. I will keep you all updated on the situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IowaLynn and ferdi2005
By the way, this is how it looks now that I've disabled the extension. As can be seen, the Safari usage itself it very low (200 MB) but I see multiple items for cached Safari content:
Bildschirmfoto 2020-11-15 um 01.00.32.png
ferdi2005 said:
So, for small periods me the difference is small with or without 1Blocker and other extensions: Safari continues to leak memory [...]
Click to expand...
Yup, I can confirm this. I checked with iStat Menus and indeed, so far at least, the memory also climbs up even though I have the extension disabled but nowhere near as fast (iStat Menus shows around 3 GB now). I think it climbs up because of the cached content entries in the activity monitor since Safari itself still uses only 200 MB so the rest (2.8 GB) have to be the cached content I think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ferdi2005
I don't have 1Blocker installed and I see the same issue on 2019 MBP 16. I was lucky to grab this screenshot yesterday.. today it just freezes the computer completely and needs a hard reset.


Screen Shot 2020-11-16 at 11.31.49 AM.png
 
ferdi2005 said:
Thank you all really much for your help, let's remain in contact and understand how to fix.
Click to expand...
Okay, so as promised, here's an update: Alex from 1Blocker support got back to me :) Here are a few notes:

- He confirms that there's a memory leak in the current version of Safari but it is not clear yet if it is caused by 1Blocker or the browser itself.
- They are investigating the issue right now and will fix it asap once they figure out why it happens

And great news: He told me that disabling the 1Blocker Button extension in Safari > Preferences > Extensions fixes the problem. And from some short testing I can indeed say that this fixes the issue for me. Content still gets blocked, just the 1Blocker button is missing.

I hope this helps others who also have this issue.

Have a great day everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mirv
Another update: The 1Blocker team just released an update to fix the memory leak issue by reverting back to the blue 1Blocker button in Safari as a temporary workaround. Apparently, the monochrome one caused the issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quackers
May I bump this? I have ZERO extensions and am noticing the Safari cache gets HUGE in Activity Monitor. I know how to clear the cache manually through the Develop button, but I wish safari could do that every time I close it out. I'm not having luck finding any apps that *confirmed* can do this automatically... has anyone found one that does that yet? Plenty of ad blockers and stuff, but I just wish the cache would clear every time I close Safari. Thanks :D
 
1609477151423.png

i have a 2013 mac pro. 12 cores. 128gb ram. all i have is safari open with a few tabs. nothing special on the tabs. never happens when i use chrome. only safari. doesn't make sense to me.
 
Choose a system wide ad blocker - AdGuard Pro -

Old days used Firefox and relied on NoScript
 
chris4565 said:
Do you always get this on the same website? I e. g. always encounter this on one specific website.
Click to expand...
shows up on all the tabs that are open. it's not every browsing experience. every week vs every day. even though my browsing habits don't change frequently. that one happened to be twitter. shows up on espn, wx, local news channel site.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chris4565
Safari just runs like garbage on my 2015 mbp retina. I keep trying to make it work for me and always end up back on brave.
 
jeyf said:
you dont have to use Safari
Click to expand...
True. But you would have thought that as Apple make both the hardware and the software, that they could make Safari less problematic. It's as if they don't do much testing.
I used Safari up until Catalina and would still like to use it, but have now gone over to Chrome - which just works.
 
Hi, normally each opened web page within Safari (14.1) use a low amount of memory (around 50-60Mb). With time, it may happen that each page use up to 1Gb or more. As suggested as a fix in a video several years back (
), you may need to clean up some safari files, in particular:

  • the Safari folder in the Library folder (~/Library),
  • the com.apple.safari in ~/Library/Containers.
To be safe, do the following:

  1. close Safari,
  2. move the ~/Library/Safari to the Desktop (e.g. ~/Desktop/Library/Safari)
  3. move the ~/Library/Containers/com.apple.safari to the Desktop (e.g. ~/Desktop/Library/Containers/com.apple.safari)
  4. reopen Safari
  5. move back your bookmarks (e.g. ~/Desktop/Library/Safari/Bookmarks.plist) to the ~/Library/Safari folder
You can check in Activity Monitor that Safari and the Safari Web Content items use a reasonably low memory.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back