There is a certain beauty and charm in simplicity to me.
Well, the original Mac is widely recognised as a classic design, so that
shouldn't be contentious.
However, in terms of overall appearance I don't think there's much wrong with the looks of most of Apple's existing range - it's still minimalist with clean lines and (mostly) neutral colours. The devils are in the details.
That beige color only reminds me of the IBM PC clones and the generic PC market back in the 80s and 90s.
...and would have turned a lovely shade of nicotine yellow/brown by now. However, it was the size, shape and semi-portability that made it stand out at the time. Certainly the design of the 1984 Mac wouldn't make any sense with modern technology.
Anyway - if you're going to make computers for colour graphics work, they should be grey/black/neutral silver so that they don't distract from what is on the screen. The whole 2004-2010 iMac ethos is "we made the computer disappear" - in 2021 it became "We made the computer disappear, then we painted it bright metallic orange!".
Do you honestly think Steve Jobs wouldn't have jumped at the chance to create this...
He pretty much did, since conceptually it's clearly a descendent of the 2004 17"/20" iMac G5. Yet it's the predecessor to that - the "Luxo Jr" model - that everybody seems to get misty eyed about.
As for the details (the 24" iMac is the one current Mac design I
really don't like, practical or not) - Maybe he'd have had Strong Opinions on making something
so thin that it didn't have space for an internal power supply or proper Ethernet and power connectors. Maybe he'd have grabbed the iMac team (working on white bezels) and the MacBook team (working on notches which assume black bezels) and cracked their heads together. (Yes, I know the iMac doesn't have a notch, but kiss goodbye to having a common design language between iMac and MacBook Air).
Now...if you want to see a Mac form-factor that IMO could survive a re-birth with a modern screen and internals, I give you this, with Mac Studio Max internals and a 24" display from the current iMac:
...the main point of reviving that would be that it was
fun (
Luxo Jr and all that). Not something that has been seen in Mac designs (apart, maybe, from the Dalmatian/Flower Power iMacs which I'm not so sure about...).
My beef is that the Microsoft Surface Studio should have been made by Apple. Love the concept (but the actual tech specs make Macs look like a bargain).