I'm a recent switcher but long-time Apple fan. I just always thought I couldn't afford a Mac. All the typical stuff you hear from PC people--"I can get a PC for $500", etc. Apple needs to push the iApps more and try to push the fact that they are free, included with the system and that for many users you may never need to buy additional software. The fact that they don't market this much makes me wonder if iLife will soon lose its free status.
I was actually very successful in making movies on my WinXP box with Pinnalce Studio. Studio has given thousands of users mass headaches but I was one of the lucky ones who was able to use the software to its full potential: edit, render and burn to DVD. But, it still wasn't a Mac, and it still wasn't the iApps.
So, 2 weeks ago I got a refurb 1ghz 17" iMac and I love it. My wife is not a computer person but she loves ordering prints thru iPhoto. We are 100% digital now. I also use iPhoto to email pics to computer savy people.
I also picked up an iPod and now I always have tunes for my 1 hour commute. I haven't organized my collection into playlists yet. I have downloaded a few AppleScripts that make generic playlists. I have purchased 2 albums from iTMS and my wife purchased about 20 Barbara Striesand songs (I know...)
I have already burned 2 full movies to iDVD with excellent results and with absolutely no issues at all. "It just works". I used the "book" theme for my latest movie and my wife almost fell over, she just loved it. I told her it was because I now have the iMac and she forgot that she was upset that I spent the money!
The movies are the killer app for me. We have 2 kids and the grandparents are 7 hours away. I now create movies of the kids and send those off as gifts to the grandparents and great-grandparents. It is a personal gift--much better than a sweater--and they love receiving the discs.
I've tried putting photos and video on the web, sending thru emails, etc. But nothing comes close to the ease of just sticking a DVD in their set-top DVD player. Anyone can do it and there is no issues with quality, download speeds, memory errors, etc.
The older generation also is still very attached to a printed photo. They don't like to view photos on a computer screen--they want to hold it and pass it around. This was (is) such a great feature of iPhoto. It's not cheap, but people don't realize that printing at home is not cheap either. Calculate your cost-per-print and you'll see it add up.
The only issue I have is that I think I've outgrown iMovie. Pinnacle Studio is able to do much more than iMovie--and it should--it is a $99 package. Studio includes SmartSound (Soundtrack lite) and a great titling package--TitleDeko. I actually miss those pieces and I'm currently looking for software on the Mac. I'm also going to start my next project with Final Cut Express.
If anyone knows of good sites for learning FCE please pass them on. Also, if anyone knows of a "Soundtrack-lite" app for OS X please let me know. I want to be able to grab free music, slice and dice it, and place it in my movies.
Thanks. Sorry for the novel!