Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

If you had to choose

  • Notch + Face ID

    Votes: 36 60.0%
  • No notch + Touch ID under display

    Votes: 24 40.0%

  • Total voters
    60

LoveToMacRumors

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Feb 15, 2015
2,672
2,843
Canada
I got the iPhone X since it launched, i'm fine with the notch, but it's not something you could ever just not notice it.
The notch is there mostly because of the components of the Face ID, which most other flagship phones doesn't have, which allow them to only use a small hole for the front camera.

Now for you, is it worth it, do you prefer the notch + face id, or no notch + touch id under display.
 
I would prefer to have the notch and Touch ID under the screen. I hated the notch initially but I'm used to it. I do think this pandemic has shown a necessity for Touch ID in the future.
 
Oh my god, the notch! THE NOTCH!! 😫
NOT THAT UGLY ABOMINATION AGAIN!!
My worst and saddest moments in life are ALL related to that stupid and evil notch. 🥺
My wife left me, my kids don't talk to me anymore and I got a really ichy rash on my penis.

CURSE YOU, NOTCH!!😠
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Barbareren
I bet all those who love the notch, when Apple gives an option between a "notched" screen and a full screen...they will be buying the full screen phone because somehow they started to "notice the notch" again.
 
I bet all those who love the notch, when Apple gives an option between a "notched" screen and a full screen...they will be buying the full screen phone because somehow they started to "notice the notch" again.
What a stupid statement.🙄 Nobody "loves" the notch, but they simply don't care about it.
And yes, if we would get full functional Face ID without a notch (or even a camera punch hole), I bet everyone would get the full screen phone.
 
What a stupid statement.🙄 Nobody "loves" the notch, but they simply don't care about it.
And yes, if we would get full functional Face ID without a notch (or even a camera punch hole), I bet everyone would get the full screen phone.
they say they don't notice it, so why buy a full screen? because they do...
 
  • Like
Reactions: snipr125
I propose another option, No Notch with Power button Touch ID (with selfie camera in hole punch or slim bezel). If Apple can perfect under screen fingerprint scanning then this is fine by me also, but the technology is finicky at the moment. Face ID is completely useless for me as it gives me eye strain, so i am biased in this regard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: saber32au
I voted Notch + Face ID. For me, and I respect that others are free to be awkward, anachronistic, antediluvian luddites with a morbid attachment to old technology, clinging to it like Norman Bates to his mother, Face ID was a huge step forward and the sensors have to go somewhere. Also, I would lose the selfie camera altogether rather than have the grotesque absurdity of a punch hole.

Just one cranky old man's opinions, no serious offence intended. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: adamhenry
I thought my answer would immediately be Touch ID under the display, but after seeing the issues my brother had with his Samsung phones and glass screen protectors rendering the Touch ID useless, I'm hesitant now. I know Apple would probably do a better job with their execution, but I'd like to see user reviews before jumping on board.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fred Zed
I thought my answer would immediately be Touch ID under the display, but after seeing the issues my brother had with his Samsung phones and glass screen protectors rendering the Touch ID useless, I'm hesitant now. I know Apple would probably do a better job with their execution, but I'd like to see user reviews before jumping on board.
Very good answer. And also very true.
 
I like face id. I would be open to a solution that provided both face id and touch id, but if i had to choose only one, face id with the notch wins for me every time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fred Zed
Once you go Face ID you never go back, don't want them crappy, slow, unreliable, under display fingerprint readers that are currently being used on android phones. 🧐📱
 
For me I prefer Face ID vs Touch ID. At first I was kind of put off by the notch but now I’m fine with it. I do miss Touch ID in some situations though.
 
Oh my god, the notch! THE NOTCH!!
NOT THAT UGLY ABOMINATION AGAIN!!
My worst and saddest moments in life are ALL related to that stupid and evil notch.
My wife left me, my kids don't talk to me anymore and I got a really ichy rash on my penis.

CURSE YOU, NOTCH!!

I highly doubt it was due to the notch but whatever you have to tell yourself .
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.