Mabey the brightness has decreased but try pressing the F1 and F2 keys and see if the brightness suits your needs.
Not sure if this would help but run the hardware test on it. I think it boot and hold 'D'.
I have the opposite problem, my iMac is so bright I have it turned down as far as ti will go and its still far to bright for me. But I am coming from an older laptop so maybe its my eyes getting used to it.
My Dad's 24" had much better brightness control then my new 24". His is also an aluminum as is mine. He had his screen replaced due to gradiant issue that was extremely obvious without tests.