Compuwar, I agree with you that it is not the BEST and not the sturdiest one in the world, but about meeting the criteria of the OP
I think it's a stretch to say it meets the criteria since we don't know if the OP intends to shoot in windy conditions, off boardwalks over marshes, etc. We don't know if they intend to spend time in the field in the middle of the winter when a metal leg set can hurt you if you touch bare skin with it. I also think that underbuying a tripod is bad- because when you start to approach the limits of a tripod, you potentially affect every image you take with it. If you under-buy at $100, then you under-buy at $200 a couple of years later, spending $250 up-front saves you money. If your intent is to take sharp pictures, then sturdiness should be a primary criterion.
Please don't tell me you consider lightweight but sturdy a tripod that weighs more than 10 pounds??? This is a beginner as far as I can tell.
Actually, yes- I do consider it light weight. It's carbon fiber specifically so I can hike with it. It's a pound lighter than the Berlebach I used to shoot MF off of. I tried to convince myself that a really small and light Bogen leg set was "really sturdy" early on, since I could shoot MF and even 4x5 off of it, but when I actually tested it against a larger (Mamiya CF) tripod in a store, it was immediately obvious that I was deluding myself, especially when it came to sharpness at the long end.
Beginning means you generally need a more sturdy tripod, not a less sturdy one- as your technique with telephotos isn't as practiced, and if the OP decides they want to do more nature photography and gets longer lenses, then they'll be buying a new tripod if they don't go with something sturdy up front (or they'll be missing lots of great shots.)
How does "beginner" even enter into the equation? A tripod is either sturdy or it isn't. It's either going to last you a lifetime, or it's going to be replaced several times. None of that has any relation to how long the photographer has been hitting the button.
You can spend a lot of money by going cheap early. Since nobody's yet pointed to the Thom Hogan article in this thread, I'll do it:
http://www.bythom.com/support.htm
While the prices in the article are beatable with today's equipment, the premise is the same and the money you save in the long run ends up being a lot- trust me- I've been through it, and I spent more getting to a 1500 series Gitzo than the Gitzo was by a long shot. I've got not so sharp images from doing the wrong thing. Dramatic landscapes happen when the weather is moving in.
More importantly, a sturdy tripod is just that- even when the legs aren't spread out fully because there's only so much room to set up. Even when there are people walking nearby. Even when there's a huge wind coming off the side. If you've got a decent camera store nearby, that stocks at least a dozen tripods, go and look for yourself. Set them up, press down on them and move around- see what materials and what sizes are and aren't sturdy- because I guarantee that if you actually test and you're honest about it pretty-much every leg set that's under $200 will be on the sucky side of the test. When you start to add in "Can I deploy this with gloves on," "what happens when I plop this down in a muddy marsh for the next five years?" and things that nature photography entails when it's not "pull over to the side of the road and snap a shot" the field narrows even more.
I believe that you believe that the Slik is sturdy, but I gave my history because my perspective of sturdy includes a lot of landscape and nature photography with equipment that challenges the concept of sturdy. I haven't shot MF or LF in years, and likely won't again. I replaced the base of my Gitzo with a hooked one to hang a pack from it to increase stability even though I haven't needed to do so in years.
I'm in ok, but nowhere near the best shape of my life. I'm probably older than 95% of the people here, yet, I'm the one who isn't ruling out carrying an extra 10lbs while hiking in the field. (I'm happy not to be carrying a 60lb pack, 20lbs of body armor, an M60 and wearing combat boots in 100 degree heat- 35lbs of camera gear and the ability to stop whenever I want? No worries.)