I just got a 9 for Christmas that replaced my terribly obsolete 1st Gen Air. I like it a lot so far. Coming from a 2013 Air like I did either one will be a dramatic upgrade. Depends on how much storage is really needed. I get by just fine with 64gb on an ipad bc everything is set to optimized storage—I only store files locally on my Mac. But if he doesn’t have a computer then it might make more sense to have more storage.