Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iThinkurBeats

macrumors member
Original poster
May 8, 2015
53
48
Vero fast rendering in video editing.
The benchmark are amazing.

IMG-0148.png


IMG-0151.png


IMG-0143.png
 
Yes they are amazing. Probably Apples best device imo.
… until the next one 😅
The same file, rendering, 10;36 minutes with M5 and 16;27 for the M2.
In mobility, iPad born for mobility, is a big difference.
so the M2 is still fast, and the M5 is … faster. It is not a revolution, but just an evolution. To be honest I was expecting more by this upgrade from M4 to M5.
 
… until the next one 😅

so the M2 is still fast, and the M5 is … faster. It is not a revolution, but just an evolution. To be honest I was expecting more by this upgrade from M4 to M5.
I honestly didn't imagine what this iPad Pro M5 would be like.
The iPad Pro M4 was fine as it was.
I'm very happy with iPadOS, which makes the iPad more interesting.
I never expect big changes from one model to the next; I don't have any particular needs to want something different.
 
… until the next one 😅

so the M2 is still fast, and the M5 is … faster. It is not a revolution, but just an evolution. To be honest I was expecting more by this upgrade from M4 to M5.
the CPU performance increase is very modest compared to M4. It's just like M1 to M2, modest CPU increase, bigger GPU increase (if you have anything that uses that GPU power)
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlyingDutch
the CPU performance increase is very modest compared to M4. It's just like M1 to M2, modest CPU increase, bigger GPU increase (if you have anything that uses that GPU power)
M5 is CPU +15% and GPU +35% ROM +20%
a lot? a little? I don't know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RevTEG
M5 is CPU +15% and GPU +35% ROM +20%
a lot? a little? I don't know.
CPU, a little. M4 was a much bigger jump. Already vs M3, on iPad pro even more as there was no M3.
Personally I have no use for the GPU power as I don't game or use anything that takes advantage of the increase in power. For me the main deal with M5 is RAM, as I had issues with 8GB M4. The speed increase vs M4 matters 0 to me. I can barely feel the difference with M1, let alone with M4 (I have the A9X, A10X, A12X, M1, M2, M4 and M5 iPad pro).
 
… until the next one 😅

so the M2 is still fast, and the M5 is … faster. It is not a revolution, but just an evolution. To be honest I was expecting more by this upgrade from M4 to M5.

Yes I meant the whole iPad Pro line from the 2018 model onwards.
 
Yeah, yeah. We know.

But what's the point of that power if you can only use it for web browsing and reading files (or editing videos at most, for high-end professionals)?
 
Yeah, yeah. We know.

But what's the point of that power if you can only use it for web browsing and reading files (or editing videos at most, for high-end professionals)?
When you use a tablet on the go—and tablets are designed for mobility, unlike a PC that must sit on a desk—being able to render quickly and reduce export or processing times is essential.
You can render a video in 40 minutes, but if it takes 20 minutes, it's even better. You'll produce more with mobility, which helps keep the battery from draining after just a little bit of work.

Obviously we are talking about a product that is purchased by those who need it and use it for its qualities, it would make no sense to assume the opposite.
 
When you use a tablet on the go—and tablets are designed for mobility, unlike a PC that must sit on a desk—being able to render quickly and reduce export or processing times is essential.
You can render a video in 40 minutes, but if it takes 20 minutes, it's even better. You'll produce more with mobility, which helps keep the battery from draining after just a little bit of work.

Obviously we are talking about a product that is purchased by those who need it and use it for its qualities, it would make no sense to assume the opposite.

But anything before M5 could already render very fast. And even if there is a significant difference for video editors, it's a very niche market compared to all other users.

Also, chances are if you need rendering that fast, you are also better off with a device with a more complete system, such as a Macbook Pro. It will be even faster while not being that much bulkier – because let's face it, a Macbook is already very light as-is.

I honestly don't see many scenarios where the portability difference would be so significant for movie editing and exporting that would specifically justify bringing an iPad but would make a Macbook too heavy, especially when you could get even lighter models which are more powerful / versatile than an iPad.
 
But anything before M5 could already render very fast. And even if there is a significant difference for video editors, it's a very niche market compared to all other users.

Also, chances are if you need rendering that fast, you are also better off with a device with a more complete system, such as a Macbook Pro. It will be even faster while not being that much bulkier – because let's face it, a Macbook is already very light as-is.

I honestly don't see many scenarios where the portability difference would be so significant for movie editing and exporting that would specifically justify bringing an iPad but would make a Macbook too heavy, especially when you could get even lighter models which are more powerful / versatile than an iPad.
Rendering in 7 minutes or 10 minutes on the go makes a big difference.
This is a niche product.
If you don't do these things, you'll buy something else at a lower price.

What's right or wrong for you doesn't necessarily match my needs.
For me, a new iPhone would be pointless, and I won't buy one. For others, it might be an Apple Watch or an iPad Pro.

I had a MacBook Pro in 2017 for a few months and a MacBook Pro M1 in 2020, but I resold them.
For me, the iPad is much more useful and functional.
Everyone has their own needs.
Not all products have to be mainstream.
 
Rendering in 7 minutes or 10 minutes on the go makes a big difference.
This is a niche product.
If you don't do these things, you'll buy something else at a lower price.

What's right or wrong for you doesn't necessarily match my needs.
For me, a new iPhone would be pointless, and I won't buy one. For others, it might be an Apple Watch or an iPad Pro.

I had a MacBook Pro in 2017 for a few months and a MacBook Pro M1 in 2020, but I resold them.
For me, the iPad is much more useful and functional.
Everyone has their own needs.
Not all products have to be mainstream.

We will agree to disagree.

An iPad is more practical in some scenarios, yes. But it's definitely not more USEFUL than Macbook.
Just name one thing the iPad can do that the Macbook cannot that's critical. The only thing I can think of is using the Apple pencil, which is an artificial limitation and is definitely addressable.

Rendering in 7 minutes or 10 minutes on the go makes a big difference.

You are surely NOT saying the Macbook CANNOT render / export video in 7 or 10 minutes while being portable, right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Digitalguy
We will agree to disagree.

An iPad is more practical in some scenarios, yes. But it's definitely not more USEFUL than Macbook.
Just name one thing the iPad can do that the Macbook cannot that's critical. The only thing I can think of is using the Apple pencil, which is an artificial limitation and is definitely addressable.
Interact with the screen through touch. That’s pretty critical
 
Interact with the screen through touch. That’s pretty critical

In most scenarios, not really. And especially if you need to control your device remotely (which is far more likely), having to use touch is actually a hindrance. And I definitely do not see a general scenario where you MUST use touch to edit and export videos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Digitalguy
In most scenarios, not really. And especially if you need to control your device remotely (which is far more likely), having to use touch is actually a hindrance. And I definitely do not see a general scenario where you MUST use touch to edit and export videos.
I didn’t say touch to export videos. You ever tried to play Angry Birds with a mouse? ****’s wild
 
  • Haha
Reactions: _Mitchan1999
Rendering in 7 minutes or 10 minutes on the go makes a big difference.
This is a niche product.
If you don't do these things, you'll buy something else at a lower price.

What's right or wrong for you doesn't necessarily match my needs.
For me, a new iPhone would be pointless, and I won't buy one. For others, it might be an Apple Watch or an iPad Pro.

I had a MacBook Pro in 2017 for a few months and a MacBook Pro M1 in 2020, but I resold them.
For me, the iPad is much more useful and functional.
Everyone has their own needs.
Not all products have to be mainstream.

I wholly agree as I do video rendering - and large RAW image processing - on the road, all on my Pro. And I don't want a MacBook - my M4 and now M5 Pro replaced my laptops.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: snipr125
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.