Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

katie ta achoo

Blogger emeritus
Original poster
May 2, 2005
9,166
5
I gifted a song to a friend of mine in NYC as I was talking to him on Adium.

I sent it, he downloaded, and even sent me a dorky screenshot of the playlist it made ("songs from KT").

BUT, my account has not been charged for it.
So basically the song was free-free?

I mean, I can tell my account hasn't been charged-- my friend gave me a $15 iTunes gift card earlier today, and it still said $15. It went down to $13.93 after I bought one song...
but shouldn't it be at $12.86?

I'm so confused.. where did that $1.07 go? (or where did it not go, more like it!)

This happening to anyone else?
 
I'm still getting charged $0.82 when I buy songs charged to PayPal...who's complaining?
 
Do you have a credit card attached to your account? Gifts come out of the CC rather than your account if you have one.
 
Nermal said:
Do you have a credit card attached to your account? Gifts come out of the CC rather than your account if you have one.

Oh.
Uh.
Crap.

I... see...

I will be giving my mother $2.14 in cash.

and here, I thought I beat the system. Bahaha.
 
Nermal said:
Do you have a credit card attached to your account? Gifts come out of the CC rather than your account if you have one.
That really sucks. Poor service by Apple. Do they have this in writing anywhere? If not, I'd try to fight it. Not that $2.14 is worth fighting about since you have to pay it anyway, but it's principle.
 
grapes911 said:
That really sucks. Poor service by Apple. Do they have this in writing anywhere? If not, I'd try to fight it. Not that $2.14 is worth fighting about since you have to pay it anyway, but it's principle.

I'll just whine about it to the genius bar. Maybe one of them'll give me $2.14 in cash to shut me up.

Mua-hah-hah!!

Hm... I'll email iTMS. I'd rather not be charging things to my mother's credit card.
 
Nermal said:
Yes. Don't ask me to find it now, but I've seen it before - that's how I know about it.
http://www.apple.com/support/itunes/musicstore/gift/ said:
I
In the rare instance that a song, audiobook or album is deleted from the iTunes Music Store while your gift is in transit, we will cancel your gift so you can send something else to your recipient. The entire purchase price of your gift will be automatically refunded to your credit card in this case.

that?
 
Nermal said:
Yes. Don't ask me to find it now, but I've seen it before - that's how I know about it.
That's OK. I believe you. You've earned enough credit around here for me to take your word on it. ;)

That still is a poor policy, IMO.
 
katie ta achoo said:

No, the message I saw was very clear, specifically stating that a credit card would be used. Bear in mind that I would've seen it on the Australian store.
 
Nermal said:
No, the message I saw was very clear, specifically stating that a credit card would be used. Bear in mind that I would've seen it on the Australian store.

Crazy Aussies! :p

I'll keep poking around, see if anything says that.
I've already sent an email to Apple though...

Yeah, $2.14 isn't much, but our other credit card recently had over $2k of fraudulent charges charged to it, and my parents are really vigilant about the statements. (this happened about a week after I tied it with the PayPal Account, so they're really weary about online houplah and shopping right now.)
 
grapes911 said:
That really sucks. Poor service by Apple. Do they have this in writing anywhere? If not, I'd try to fight it. Not that $2.14 is worth fighting about since you have to pay it anyway, but it's principle.
It'll cost more for the phone call. Why bother. give it a rest and call it a day. You have learned and it was a very cheap lesson. Besides, I am sure that this info is somewhere in the EULA that most people never bother to read (me included)
 
I think is has something to do with the internet connection the person is using while downloading from iTunes.

You don't get charged till after you download it. As soon as you download a song from iTunes, it wraps the DRM, then charges your account. I'm assuming that if the process gets interrupted, then you won't get charged (?).

My neighbor has gotten away with a couple of free albums. He downloaded them, and he noticed he didn't get charged [Its been weeks BTW, still nothing]. I'm assuming its because of his flakey internet [384k DSL] connection. He didn't intend to do it, but he's not complaining either.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.