Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

DaMax85

macrumors member
Original poster
May 19, 2011
88
34
I just upgraded to a base model MacBook Air M1 from a 12" MacBook Retina, both with 256 GB's of storage. I used Migration Assistant to transfer my data from Mac-to-Mac and I now have an extra 40 GB's of used space on the new Mac. Has anyone else had this issue? If so, how did you solve?
 

BLUEDOG314

macrumors 6502
Dec 12, 2015
379
120
I have two things to say on this. First the helpful part, then the part you probably don't want to hear but will likely produce better results.

First, have you taken any steps to identifying what the 40GB extra used space is? Depending on the macOS version you migrated from (and even if it is the same as the new machine), I would expect the used space to be different to some degree. A few gigs, sure, 40 not so much. I would try running something like Omnidisk Sweeper to get a directory breakdown of storage. Another possibility is maybe after the transfer the new Mac ignored your photos library and redownloaded everything in another library from iCloud....just a thought. If you post some screenshots of Omni run on both new and old machines I may be able to help better.

Now for the real advice. Never use migration assistant. It is understandable that you want your new machine to look exactly like your old one, but if you have a ton of apps highly customized, plugins, etc migration assistant will only disappoint you. It is more work but it's best to start with a clean install, manually move your files via target disk, flash drive or whatever, then install all programs fresh. If your file storage structure, apps, etc allow for it you will save yourself a lot of time in the long run.

As a personal example, all the apps I use are either free or I have active subscriptions that allow for redownload by logging in somewhere for installers. Photos are in iCloud, all personal documents are in iCloud Drive, all work documents are in Box. Once a year for major macOS updates my machine gets a clean install. If I ever experience some catastrophic software issue (only once since using a Mac), clean install. Anyway, I digress...just a way I've been able to make my life easier.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaMax85

DaMax85

macrumors member
Original poster
May 19, 2011
88
34
I have two things to say on this. First the helpful part, then the part you probably don't want to hear but will likely produce better results.

First, have you taken any steps to identifying what the 40GB extra used space is? Depending on the macOS version you migrated from (and even if it is the same as the new machine), I would expect the used space to be different to some degree. A few gigs, sure, 40 not so much. I would try running something like Omnidisk Sweeper to get a directory breakdown of storage. Another possibility is maybe after the transfer the new Mac ignored your photos library and redownloaded everything in another library from iCloud....just a thought. If you post some screenshots of Omni run on both new and old machines I may be able to help better.

Now for the real advice. Never use migration assistant. It is understandable that you want your new machine to look exactly like your old one, but if you have a ton of apps highly customized, plugins, etc migration assistant will only disappoint you. It is more work but it's best to start with a clean install, manually move your files via target disk, flash drive or whatever, then install all programs fresh. If your file storage structure, apps, etc allow for it you will save yourself a lot of time in the long run.

As a personal example, all the apps I use are either free or I have active subscriptions that allow for redownload by logging in somewhere for installers. Photos are in iCloud, all personal documents are in iCloud Drive, all work documents are in Box. Once a year for major macOS updates my machine gets a clean install. If I ever experience some catastrophic software issue (only once since using a Mac), clean install. Anyway, I digress...just a way I've been able to make my life easier.
That's good advice. I'd normally do the former. I had just recently done a clean install and spent a lot of time cleaning and organizing my last Mac, so I thought I could get away with it this time. I guess not. :-\
 

DaMax85

macrumors member
Original poster
May 19, 2011
88
34
That's good advice. I'd normally do the former. I had just recently done a clean install and spent a lot of time cleaning and organizing my last Mac, so I thought I could get away with it this time. I guess not. :-\
I have two things to say on this. First the helpful part, then the part you probably don't want to hear but will likely produce better results.

First, have you taken any steps to identifying what the 40GB extra used space is? Depending on the macOS version you migrated from (and even if it is the same as the new machine), I would expect the used space to be different to some degree. A few gigs, sure, 40 not so much. I would try running something like Omnidisk Sweeper to get a directory breakdown of storage. Another possibility is maybe after the transfer the new Mac ignored your photos library and redownloaded everything in another library from iCloud....just a thought. If you post some screenshots of Omni run on both new and old machines I may be able to help better.

Now for the real advice. Never use migration assistant. It is understandable that you want your new machine to look exactly like your old one, but if you have a ton of apps highly customized, plugins, etc migration assistant will only disappoint you. It is more work but it's best to start with a clean install, manually move your files via target disk, flash drive or whatever, then install all programs fresh. If your file storage structure, apps, etc allow for it you will save yourself a lot of time in the long run.

As a personal example, all the apps I use are either free or I have active subscriptions that allow for redownload by logging in somewhere for installers. Photos are in iCloud, all personal documents are in iCloud Drive, all work documents are in Box. Once a year for major macOS updates my machine gets a clean install. If I ever experience some catastrophic software issue (only once since using a Mac), clean install. Anyway, I digress...just a way I've been able to make my life easier.
Update: I wiped the Mac and did a clean install today and this fixed it! It must have been an issue with Migration Assistant as you mentioned. I also noticed in Disk Utility that half of my SSD was greyed out as "volumes." So I deleted the container, and did a clean wipe. Not only did I get my space back, I actually gained even more space because I am picking and choosing just what I need on this new Mac. I now have 162 GB's of free storage. This gives me a lot of breathing room and I don't storage creep will become an issue during my time with this machine. Thanks again for the warning about Migration Assistant...I'll never use it again. :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.