Mine is going back.
It's probably acceptable for a $20 band, but I wouldn't pay anywhere near the $80 original price, or even the $40 sale price.
But in my case in particular, I'm not going to keep it because whomever tore open the package while it was on the store shelf just haphazardly shoved it back in the package and creased one of the keepers.
Knowing how the store items are treated, I specifically didn't order it for pickup, hoping that I'd get an unmolested example from one of there warehouses. Instead, they just picked it off the shelf at the local store and sent one of those.
I considered keeping and it salvaging the lug adapters (which are pretty nice) and pvd buckle to have on hand, but I just want to wash my hands of it. Oh well.