Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ddrueckhammer

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Aug 8, 2004
1,181
0
America's Wang
Hello-

I am a Civil Engineering Student and make extra money for school by designing 2-D concrete and structural steel plans. i.e. roads, foundations, ponds, culverts, etc. I am proficient in AutoCAD however, I don't really want to use virtual PC to run it as it would probably be slow compared to a native app. Before I learned AutoCAD, I used Microsoft's Visio for small projects, sadly, there is not an equivalent alternative for Mac for this program either. I really prefer a command-line interface for its raw speed but it looks like most of the available apps use point and click GUIs. I have scoured the Architosh website and found the following programs may suit my needs:

PowerCAD
TurboCAD
MacDraft
VectorWorks
ArchiCAD

I really don't need 3-D capabilities as I don't plan on doing any industrial/mechanical design work in the near future but I would like maximum compatibility with Autodesk's DWG/DWF formats. If anyone has any information or experience they could share it would be appreciated.
 
a friend of mine who is an architect uses VectorWorks and regularly exchanges drawings back and forth with his engineers who all use autocad. He exports his drawings either as dwg or dxf and then the engineers do their work and send him files which he imports back into Vectorworks. In the beginning, he spent a little bit of time setting up and coordinating drawing standards. He says it all works out just fine for his needs.

for 2D you shouldn't have much of a problem making it work
 
archicad???

you could use archicad for mac . It also exports to DXF DWG ect. although it is mostly 3D based the 2D elements are better to draw with than the Autodesk apps, my opinion anyway.
 
Thanks for the suggestions. I am going to try to see if there are trial versions of VectorWorks and ArchiCAD. It would be interesting to draw in 3-D using ArchiCAD but I'm just not sure that I need that robust of a program. Also since I am eligible for the edu discount, I read that everything that you do with ArchiCAD has a watermark on the edu version....I really don't mind too much, but If a competitor doesn't have this I would be an advantage.

FYI- Omnigraffle is a good substitute for Visio on the Mac but Visio enables you to do some light drafting (floorplans) as well as charts etc...Omnigraffle seems to be geared only toward flowcharts and graphs.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.