Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mac Pro 5,1 Liquid cooling?
- Thread starter sokobanz
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The existing air coolers have all sorts of sensors in and around them... it is likely to protest like heck.
There are vids of a liquid cooled 2008 MP I think.
There are vids of a liquid cooled 2008 MP I think.
Unless you are looking for silence, you won't need liquid. The MP air cooling is very good. If temps are a little hot, install some fan control software, raise the min fan speeds a tad and be done with it.
Mac Pros Air cooling is enough for every dual 6-core Westemere Xeon, even for dual 3.46 6-Core.
I think that only way to have water cooling on CPUs is to remove every Fan in the chassis, and that is not very smart. This is only way because if any sensor on main or logic board can not detect RPM from any fan and adjust its analog control, other fans automatically go full blast, but if you remove every fan, there is no blast
Why this is not smart: you need fan for PSU, HDD bays / PCIe part of chassis to maintain safe air temps for other components.
I think that only way to have water cooling on CPUs is to remove every Fan in the chassis, and that is not very smart. This is only way because if any sensor on main or logic board can not detect RPM from any fan and adjust its analog control, other fans automatically go full blast, but if you remove every fan, there is no blast
Why this is not smart: you need fan for PSU, HDD bays / PCIe part of chassis to maintain safe air temps for other components.
Last edited:
Nope. Wont work. And it's silly. Your best bet would be to get a clear tube, pump super-cold air from the bottom-up. Then cycle it through again while constantly super-cooling.
MUCH MUCH better than liquid cooling, and it will allow you to overclock the CPU and GPUs and run them at very high temps.
Make sure their super-cooled air has little-to-no moisture.
Couldn't you theoretically add liquid cooling to the existing heatsinks? It wouldn't be as good as liquid cooling directly, but the colder the heatsinks are the colder the processors are, which would let the fans run slower or the processors to run hotter.
It'd be a lot of work for limited gain though; a more useful solution might be to just get air-conditioning, either for the room (potentially cool several machines) or just get a portable unit and have it push cold air at the computer. Obviously it cools the whole room, and the computer is going to make the air conditioning unit work harder than it needs to, but the colder the air is coming in, the more effectively it cools. Plus if you get a new machine you don't have to transfer over the liquid cooling or buy a new liquid cooling unit, and if you get especially hot weather then you're not going to mind having some spare air-conditioning
If I had a spare room where I could do something like that then it's what I'd do; namely move my computers into a discrete air-conditioned room out of the way, and either setup another machine as a dumb-terminal or see if I can video cables etc. that will work over long enough distances to route them into my various, normal temperature rooms. If you have a basement you could even partition off a part of it, provided it's dry enough.
It'd be a lot of work for limited gain though; a more useful solution might be to just get air-conditioning, either for the room (potentially cool several machines) or just get a portable unit and have it push cold air at the computer. Obviously it cools the whole room, and the computer is going to make the air conditioning unit work harder than it needs to, but the colder the air is coming in, the more effectively it cools. Plus if you get a new machine you don't have to transfer over the liquid cooling or buy a new liquid cooling unit, and if you get especially hot weather then you're not going to mind having some spare air-conditioning
If I had a spare room where I could do something like that then it's what I'd do; namely move my computers into a discrete air-conditioned room out of the way, and either setup another machine as a dumb-terminal or see if I can video cables etc. that will work over long enough distances to route them into my various, normal temperature rooms. If you have a basement you could even partition off a part of it, provided it's dry enough.
It's been started, other projects got in the way. Give me a couple of more months, but will be sooner rather than later- got to if for no other reason than to clear a lot of the junk from my office!
Already custom fab'd the water blocks to fit the 4,1 procs and Northbridge. Wanted to integrate the vreg's mounts to the proc waterblock mounts before finishing.
If I knew how to post pics from my phone here I'd share.
BTW, my 3.3 Ghz 1,1 has been running on water since 2010. Last time I changed anything in the loop was 3 years ago.
Oh yeah, sorry to resurrect the dead here. If no interest just disregard my post.
Already custom fab'd the water blocks to fit the 4,1 procs and Northbridge. Wanted to integrate the vreg's mounts to the proc waterblock mounts before finishing.
If I knew how to post pics from my phone here I'd share.
BTW, my 3.3 Ghz 1,1 has been running on water since 2010. Last time I changed anything in the loop was 3 years ago.
Oh yeah, sorry to resurrect the dead here. If no interest just disregard my post.
Hi, a little bit topic but can you share any info about your water cooled project? I’m thinking about installing setup to my dual Xeon Mac Pro 5,1
May I know what’s the reason to go water cooling? The Xeons can run 24/7 at full speed under the current Mac Pro’s air cool system even in hot (and humid) Asia. There is no way to OC the CPU. And the air cooler is not that noisy.
Water cooling may able to lower the CPU temperature, by doesn’t help in performance point of view. And Xeons has zero problem to run for years even a bit warmer.
However, the associated risk / trouble is very obvious. e.g. the cMP is not using standard mount point. Even installing the water cooler properly is already a challenge. And any liquid cooling system can leak (and probably will leak if not maintain properly).
The protential risk and benefit just doesn’t match up. High risk, low return, IMO.
You want to do it for fun? To prove it can work? Or really want to “use” it?