Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Schroedinger

macrumors regular
Original poster
Feb 12, 2004
241
0
Baltimore, MD
I'm throwing this story out there in case anybody is thinking about any of these issues.

I installed the latest version of smcFanControl on my mac pro. I had been using temperature monitoring software to keep track of the temp of the processors and 4 internal harddrives (two set up in a RAID).

The harddrives had been running between 45 and 50 Celsius, even at idle, and this seemed a little high to me based on what information I could find on the topic of harddrive heat and lifespan.

So, I installed the fan control software. Instead of the normal fan speed of 500 RPM i've got it running at 1000 RPM (as a minimum), which is just a little louder, but does amazing things to the temps. If i'm pushing the system at all, such as watching HD movies off the RAID (while de-interlacing the video), I'll push up the fan speed to 1500, which is still quiet enough not to be a bother.

The drives are now running around 30C even at a good load. Not good with the Ferenheit Celsius conversion off the top of my head, but I think that is pretty much ambient room temperature.

I was less worried under about the CPUs, but even under full load for all 4 cores (running Rosetta@home) they are running about 10-15 degrees Celsius cooler.

With the software, you can set the minimum fan speed up to 3000 RPM, which doesn't seem to get much more of a cooling gain, and sounds like a jet engine, so I don't really use that setting.
 

netnothing

macrumors 68040
Mar 13, 2007
3,822
422
NH
I'm throwing this story out there in case anybody is thinking about any of these issues.

I installed the latest version of smcFanControl on my mac pro. I had been using temperature monitoring software to keep track of the temp of the processors and 4 internal harddrives (two set up in a RAID).

The harddrives had been running between 45 and 50 Celsius, even at idle, and this seemed a little high to me based on what information I could find on the topic of harddrive heat and lifespan.

So, I installed the fan control software. Instead of the normal fan speed of 500 RPM i've got it running at 1000 RPM (as a minimum), which is just a little louder, but does amazing things to the temps. If i'm pushing the system at all, such as watching HD movies off the RAID (while de-interlacing the video), I'll push up the fan speed to 1500, which is still quiet enough not to be a bother.

The drives are now running around 30C even at a good load. Not good with the Ferenheit Celsius conversion off the top of my head, but I think that is pretty much ambient room temperature.

I was less worried under about the CPUs, but even under full load for all 4 cores (running Rosetta@home) they are running about 10-15 degrees Celsius cooler.

With the software, you can set the minimum fan speed up to 3000 RPM, which doesn't seem to get much more of a cooling gain, and sounds like a jet engine, so I don't really use that setting.

How about your memory temps? What are you running for memory?

Hs your Mac Pro ever kicked up the fans on it's own?

I just installed 2 GB of Crucial RAM and they tend to hover around 56-62 Celsius. Mac Pro never kicks the fans on.

-Kevin
 

osx-linux

macrumors member
Apr 4, 2007
45
0
That's some good info there for me. Thanks for sharing!

Was wondering how loud the fans would get if cranked up a bit. :)
 

synth3tik

macrumors 68040
Oct 11, 2006
3,951
2
Minneapolis, MN
I had smsfancontrol for my mac pro but got rid of it as I didn't like having the fans running at 1,000. I have installed 4G of RAM 4X512mb Apple and 2X1G from OWC. after the install of all the RAM my Fans now run a 600rpm instead of 500rpm and my RAM is around 150F or 66C.
 

Schroedinger

macrumors regular
Original poster
Feb 12, 2004
241
0
Baltimore, MD
I hadn't looked at RAM temps, but will take a look now. The Mac Pro never sped up the fans on its own, at least not such that I'd notice. My sense is that Apple is more comfortable with higher temps in the case than I am. Perhaps they place a greater priority on a quieter system.
 

DEXTERITY

macrumors 6502a
Aug 14, 2004
683
363
I've been reading the fan issue posts. I 'm getting a mac pro as soon as apple ships it. Are there fan/heat issues or is there something I should do to control the heat? I've new to the mac pro (had dual g5) so I'm trying to get caught up on whatever issues I need to be aware of and how to resolve them or keep any problems from arising.

thanks ...
 

Father Jack

macrumors 68020
Jan 1, 2007
2,481
1
Ireland
I have never heard my 2.66 MHz Mac Pro fans speed up either.

CPU A processor temp is 32 C
CPU B processor temp is 34 C

I have all ram slots filled
Mem module 57 C
Mem module 58 C
Mem module 62 C
Mem module 68 C

Fan 0 500 rpm
Fan 1 500 rpm
Fan 2 600 rpm
Fan 3 650 rpm

FJ
 

netnothing

macrumors 68040
Mar 13, 2007
3,822
422
NH
I hadn't looked at RAM temps, but will take a look now. The Mac Pro never sped up the fans on its own, at least not such that I'd notice. My sense is that Apple is more comfortable with higher temps in the case than I am. Perhaps they place a greater priority on a quieter system.

I think that's exactly it. It think Apple set the fan threshold limits really high. I'm glad there is smcFanControl so that we can adjust fans manually (although I really do think we should have to).

For the most part I haven't had any problems with the head. Only if I run Rember or do something processor/memory intensive was I getting some ECC Errors on the OWC RAM I installed. But then again, the temps were getting into the 170F range for the OWC RAM.

I'm running Crucial RAM now and haven't had any ECC Errors.

-Kevin
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.