Mac Pro vs 5x Mac Minis for Dev Teaching Lab?

[jimmydhp]

Hi all,

I'll be running a small teaching lab for students to learn Objective C, not sure whether I should get a single Mac Pro and try to munge it into supporting multiple simultaneous users, or get five Mac Minis and have them setup individually?

I don't mind spending a bit to get things working nicely, but my main concern is setup/takedown - I likely won't have a permanent home for these things, so anything that minimises computer config time would be best...

Thanks for any help,

Jimmyp

 

[joelypolly]

5 mac minis will work better than having 1 Mac Pro running everything. Single point of failure is never a good option

 

[MattInOz]

You'll need to cart around screens either way so...
Why not just 5 cheap iMac's and a cart
Or MacbookAirs and a pizza delivery bag?

Nothing a beginner programmer will throw at either of those machines will be an issue. They can handle reasonable sized xCode projects.

As far as I know MacPro will only handle one user active. It's something I've yet to find a solution for we be keen to know how if you get it to work.

 

[jimmydhp]

Thanks Matt and Joel, both worthy considerations. For a mba, might not the screen be a bit small for development?

 

[westrock2000]

You would still need a terminal of some kind even if the single Mac Pro was doing the back end processing. I'd say refurbished Mac Mini's if possible, something you can find for ~$400 each or so. Then everyone gets dedicated processing and memory space. Strap them to the back of the monitor

 

[jimmydhp]

Any suggestions about how I'd handle specific logins for users if I had five different machines? Is it possible to have one machine as the master 'user' system and then have users authenticate against that, or should I go with a generic 'student' profile for each machine and give each student a USB stick to retain their own data?

 

[goMac]

Thanks Matt and Joel, both worthy considerations. For a mba, might not the screen be a bit small for development?

Not really on the 13" Air. It's good for simple development. Besides, you could always buy an 11" and plug into an external display.

There is simply no way to set up a Mac Pro to do this multiuser thing you want in a reliable manner, so whatever you're going for here, just toss that option right out. One machine for each user is the way to go.

USB stick is the way for users to manage their files.

 

[funwithdesign]

Any suggestions about how I'd handle specific logins for users if I had five different machines? Is it possible to have one machine as the master 'user' system and then have users authenticate against that, or should I go with a generic 'student' profile for each machine and give each student a USB stick to retain their own data?

Have one machine running OS X server with mobile user profiles.

 

[goMac]

Have one machine running OS X server with mobile user profiles.

I don't think I'd go that route unless he had an actual server. That's a lot of strain to put on a single Mini with a not-so-fast hard drive.

Also the pack up/move requirement makes that a less nice option.

 

[jimmydhp]

Okay, looks like 5 x MBA 13" is an attractive option, with the possibility of getting some cheap 21+" monitors down the line for extra screen real estate.

As for user files, given having a central server might cause a bit of strain for a Mac Mini or whatever I was thinking what might also work is setting up each of the students with a Dropbox account and then having them login at the beginning of each class, and then logging out again at the end - would avoid the inevitable issues that arise when students forget their USB sticks etc.

Thanks for all the help so far guys, please let me know if you see any obvious flaws with my approach.

 

[azentropy]

Okay, looks like 5 x MBA 13" is an attractive option, with the possibility of getting some cheap 21+" monitors down the line for extra screen real estate.

As for user files, given having a central server might cause a bit of strain for a Mac Mini or whatever I was thinking what might also work is setting up each of the students with a Dropbox account and then having them login at the beginning of each class, and then logging out again at the end - would avoid the inevitable issues that arise when students forget their USB sticks etc.

Thanks for all the help so far guys, please let me know if you see any obvious flaws with my approach.

I'd spend a little bit more and go for the 13" rMBP over the MBA, especially now that the base has 8gb RAM standard - it is really only $200 more than the MBA if you want 8gb. With the bump it is ~30% faster and has a MUCH better screen (but I've never been a fan of the MBA screen as colors look washed out and has bad viewing angles besides not being retina). The trade off is weight.

Don't underestimate the Mac mini. While graphics are limiting for some uses, the CPU itself is no slouch. Especially the quad i7.