Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

bogdanw

macrumors 603
Original poster
Mar 10, 2009
6,099
3,011
Today (12 April 2022) iMovie has been updated (10.3.2) with improvements for Apple silicon.
I intend to buy a Mac Studio for iMovie editing and I would be interested in some real life tests.
If you can, please post screenshots of Activity Monitor with GPU & CPU history during iMovie exports. (720p/1080p/4K)
I’m not interested in FCP or other video editor, only iMovie.
 

F-Train

macrumors 68020
Apr 22, 2015
2,272
1,762
NYC & Newfoundland
Today (12 April 2022) iMovie has been updated (10.3.2) with improvements for Apple silicon.
I intend to buy a Mac Studio for iMovie editing and I would be interested in some real life tests.
If you can, please post screenshots of Activity Monitor with GPU & CPU history during iMovie exports. (720p/1080p/4K)
I’m not interested in FCP or other video editor, only iMovie.

I don't use iMovie, but I assume that, like Final Cut Pro, it uses Compressor presets for export. If that's correct, I would think that the question is what the update does to improve Compressor.
 

bogdanw

macrumors 603
Original poster
Mar 10, 2009
6,099
3,011
I don't use iMovie, but I assume that, like Final Cut Pro, it uses Compressor presets for export. If that's correct, I would think that the question is what the update does to improve Compressor.
I don’t have time to compare the files (/Applications/iMovie.app/Contents/PlugIns/Compressor/CompressorKit.bundle/Contents/Frameworks/Compressor.framework/Versions/A/Frameworks/CompressorKit.framework/Versions/A/Resources/Settings/), but I don’t think that the presets for export are relevant.
I’m interested in what ProTranscoderTool_sb does. That’s why I’m asking for GPU & CPU history data to see if iMovie manages to use the resources to the max. There is no point in buying a 48-core GPU if it’s not properly used. I’ll just buy the 32-core model.
 

eddie_ducking

Suspended
Oct 18, 2021
95
118
I'm kind of in the middle of testing other things on my base Studio Ultra at the moment, but give me a couple of days and sure .... I'm not an iMovie person, does it make any difference to the results from your perspective what the source and encoded files use for codex or have you a preference of H.264 over H.265 ? (I'm guessing it'll make a difference to encode time but possibly not to CPU/GPU utilisation). Never having used iMovie I might need a bit of hand holding unless it's defaults being used.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bogdanw

Solenoid289

macrumors member
Jun 28, 2020
53
49
Japan
I'm not a video guy but I've tested with latest iMovie 10.3.2 on M1 Max 32GB/24GPU/1TB

Here's a screenshot during exporting simple 4K project with iMovie (High Quality preset, H.264).
I'm from Japan, sorry if you can't understand the details.
Hope this helps.

screenshot2.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: bogdanw

bogdanw

macrumors 603
Original poster
Mar 10, 2009
6,099
3,011
I'm kind of in the middle of testing other things on my base Studio Ultra at the moment, but give me a couple of days and sure
Thank you, there is no rush. The source doesn’t matter. 1080p/High quality/fast setting for export.

I'm not a video guy but I've tested with latest iMovie 10.3.2 on M1 Max 32GB/24GPU/1TB

Thank you, it seems the GPU and CPU are not used to their full potential.
 

eddie_ducking

Suspended
Oct 18, 2021
95
118
Thank you, there is no rush. The source doesn’t matter. 1080p/High quality/fast setting for export.

Here you are
Mac Studio Ultra 20/48/64Gb
0 - Screenshot About this Mac.png


iMovie 10.3.2
1 - Screenshot iMovie Version.png

Input files used :-
bbb_sunflower_1080p_30fps_normal.mp4 (Duration 10min 34sec)
bbb_sunflower_2160p_30fps_normal.mp4 (Duration 10min 35sec)

Test 1:
1080p source, 1080p destination, High / Faster settings
Time taken: 1min 19sec
2 - Screenshot Selection High : Faster.png
3 - Screenshot 1080p->1080p High : Faster .... Time Taken = 1min 19sec.png

Test 2:
1080p source, 1080p destination, Highest (ProRes) / Better settings
Time taken: 32sec
4 - Screenshot Selection Highest (ProRes) : Better.png
5 - Screenshot 1080p->1080p Highest (ProRes) : Better .... Time Taken = 32sec.png

Test 3:
2160p source, 1080p destination, High / Faster settings
Time taken: 1min 20sec
6 - Screenshot 2160p->1080p High : Faster .... Time Taken = 1min 20sec.png

Test 4:
2160p source, 1080p destination, Highest (ProRes) / Better settings
Time taken: 39sec
7 - Screenshot 2160p->1080p Highest (ProRes) : Better .... Time Taken = 39sec.png

Test 5:
2160p source, 2160p destination, High / Faster settings
Time taken: 3min 41sec
8 - Screenshot 2160p->2160p High : Faster .... Time Taken = 3min 41sec.png

Test 6:
2160p source, 2160p destination, Highest (ProRes) / Better settings
Time taken: 56sec
9 - Screenshot 2160p->2160p Highest (ProRes) : Better .... Time Taken = 56sec.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: bogdanw

bogdanw

macrumors 603
Original poster
Mar 10, 2009
6,099
3,011
Test 1:
1080p source, 1080p destination, High / Faster settings
Time taken: 1min 19sec
Test 2:
1080p source, 1080p destination, Highest (ProRes) / Better settings
Time taken: 32sec
Thank you very much for all the tests. Those are encouraging results.
Just to confirm, the “Best (ProRes)” tests completed faster than the “High” ones?
 

eddie_ducking

Suspended
Oct 18, 2021
95
118
Thank you very much for all the tests. Those are encouraging results.
Just to confirm, the “Best (ProRes)” tests completed faster than the “High” ones?

Yes, in all cases. And quite significantly too. I guess that's the beauty of the hardware encoders cause the CPU usage really isn't that high at all.

I'm assuming hardware encoders were being used, I couldn't find anything to enable/disable them.

Also, I'm presently booting from a TB3 NVMe SSD to test MacOS 12.4 Beta. As such, my disk performance is less than half of the internal SSD ie. "only" 1800MB/sec or so. Can't imagine it'd have an effect on the "High" exports, but may have had a marginal one on the "Best (ProRes)" given the 41Gb size of the 4k->4k exported file.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bogdanw
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.