Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Glennsune

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Oct 3, 2008
17
0
Sweden
Ok ... so, my friend dropped his airbook into his stone floor.

The Air took a solid hit strait at the bottom corner. The computer is working just fine, nothing is broken except the pshysical apperance of course :eek:

Unfortantly he dosen't have any applecare connected to the computer (but applecare dosen't cover these kind of things anyway, or does it?), but he will most certainly get it fixed though his home insurance.

My question is ... there is an opening along the far side of the computer, is there any risk of the electronics inside taking damage from dust, and other things. Maybe he should keep the air at home and not expose it to much until he gets it fixed?
 

Attachments

  • DSC00402.JPG
    DSC00402.JPG
    497.9 KB · Views: 289

synth3tik

macrumors 68040
Oct 11, 2006
3,951
2
Minneapolis, MN
Ooch!:(

As long as he is not going to be pouring water into the opening all should be ok. Dust is fine. Maybe not a sand storm, but day to day travel should be ok.
And, no Apple care would not fix that.
 

Father Jack

macrumors 68020
Jan 1, 2007
2,481
1
Ireland
Ohhh bugg*r :(

I wouldn't think a little bit of dust would be a major problem but a small amount of rain certainly could be .. :eek:

I would keep it indoors until the repair is carrier out.
 

chewbaccacabra

macrumors regular
Mar 20, 2008
185
0
I bet the repair is going to be almost the cost of a $1349 refurb . . . :eek:

There sure have been lot's of damaged AIRs posted on here lately. :(
 

n0de

macrumors 6502
Feb 3, 2005
321
0
Assuming all is OK with the internals, and you are afraid to open it up, powerbookmedic.com has both the shell parts you need.
 

Sesshi

macrumors G3
Jun 3, 2006
8,113
1
One Nation Under Gordon
Bad luck. It's unfortunately what happens when you make laptops out of 'dead' metals of inadequate rigidity.

As others have said there shouldn't be many problems in using it until it can be repaired / replaced. It might even improve the cooling...
 

ppnkg

macrumors 6502a
Jul 29, 2005
510
6
UK
this probably demonstrates how unibody makes perfect sense? I can't imagine the old macbooks surviving that hit,
 

gooddeal

macrumors regular
Aug 3, 2008
207
0
PA
I don't think it's wise to try to claim something this small against your home policy. I heard that if you make claims too many times, they will drop you.
 

BanjoBanker

macrumors 6502
Aug 10, 2006
354
0
Mt Brook, AL
If it were my MBA, I would have a chat over lunch with my insurance agent over a hypothetical computer crash and would it be wise to file a claim. I handled a minor accident my son was involved in this way and I was advised not to file a claim. My agent told me the claim would increase the likelihood of a review due to a previous accident which had been reported. Depending on your friend's history with his carrier, he may come out okay. :D
 

SFStateStudent

macrumors 604
Aug 28, 2007
7,496
3
San Francisco California, USA
I was sitting in class banging away on my MBA and the professor was lecturing and as he went into one of his rants, he was making a gesture with his hand and he smacked my MBA and sent it into a fall off of my desk, but I was able to catch it before it struck the ground. He totally apologized, but I'm certain it could have ended up just like the OP's...:eek:
 

allmIne

macrumors 6502a
Sep 17, 2008
771
0
United Kingdom
Bad luck. It's unfortunately what happens when you make laptops out of 'dead' metals of inadequate rigidity.

As others have said there shouldn't be many problems in using it until it can be repaired / replaced. It might even improve the cooling...

To be honest, a super slim laptop like that will always come out wrecked if it hits a stone floor. That's not really Apple's problem. If anything, the fact the internals are ok is testament to good construction.

If I crash my car, the car should, ideally, be cosmetically wrecked, but keep me safe.
 

Sesshi

macrumors G3
Jun 3, 2006
8,113
1
One Nation Under Gordon
To be honest, a super slim laptop like that will always come out wrecked if it hits a stone floor. That's not really Apple's problem. If anything, the fact the internals are ok is testament to good construction.

Not my Sony G11 for starters. And that was 200 grams lighter than the Air.

No, this is simply a testament to Apple's obsession with a material not all that suitable to build laptop / chassis' out of for reasons of looks, unifying their manufacturing methods and other reasons which can only work because the vast majority of the rather vacuous users of the company's products don't go 'It's easily damaged, it's crap' but 'It's easily damaged, I'll baby it / spend even more money on third-party accessories trying in vain to protect it'. This works because said third-party accessories serves to... well, accessorise, and that is what the average Apple user loves, or the product is babied because it's much more frequently a less commoditised personal purchase.

To have good structural integrity in the Air there must be more material than there is, which would make it heavier. The same goes for the new MB/MBPs which have adopted the same chassis arrangement. As for impact resistance - forget it. The actual main 'chassis' on the Air - which is the case, the top shell that the keyboard mounts to - is not exactly lightweight when you compare it to chassis' on other better engineered ultralight machines. 'Aircraft-grade' aluminium, even when the block is cold-rolled to the level of relative hardness of the plates that the Macbook Air / MB / MBP chassis are machined from, is still pretty soft - and more importantly, has nothing in the way of being able to 'bounce back' from an impact like say polycarbonate. But sure, I'll give you that it looks better than polycarbonate, moulded mag or thermoplastic short-fibre carbon.

Apple's inferiority in materials / structural & other engineering is not new in the Return of the Jobs era. Take iPods - how long did it take Apple to make a scratch-resistant screen? I had a < 3-year-old Nano until recently which frankly looked like crap, and the material hasn't changed for the Classic - only now they've changed to glass for other machines. In contrast I have a 5-year-old Sony player used in much the same circumstances whose clear plastic panels still look reasonably untouched and a > 2 year old Sony flash player which is three-quarters clear panel and has been treated very badly but still looks a hell of a lot better than the Nano.

Apple of now are excellent designers - that's where they get you. But in reality, they can't engineer worth a **** although they do a superb job of hyping up whatever inadequate but different method they've used, and their products - and their most enthusiastic users - are testament to this.
 

Scott6666

macrumors 68000
Feb 2, 2008
1,511
980
I'm amazed the screen didn't crack/break given the force that caused the metal deformation.

I guess the metal acted as a kind of an airbag for the rest of the unit. I think most computers would have died outright.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.