macbook silicone keyboard protector

[natness]

Is anyone using a silicone keyboard protector with their macbook? I see that the macbook-specific iSkin is out

http://www.iskin.com/store/I2shop_ptmb.tpl

and for a lot less, the Exo

http://www.onlycooltoys.com/index.php?p=catalog&parent=29&pg=1

Is anyone using either of these? What is your experience? How does it fit? How does it impact the keyboard feel? And maybe this is a silly question, but could it block airflow to the computer? Could it cause overheating?

Thanks,
Natalie

 

[ripfrankwhite]

I would love to hear from some owners. I've gotta get one, just dont know which one. I guess I'll be the first and then review it.

 

[DZ/015]

I use one with my desktop and my powerbook. They are great for keeping dirt and other undesirable items from entering your keyboard. They do make your typing slow down slightly, however.

 

[ripfrankwhite]

I ordered the black Exo. I almost ordered the iSkin, but it cost a lot more and didn't offer black. I'll post some pics and reviews when I get mine.

 

[emotistically]

I almost want to get the black one for my white macbook. I think it would look cool to just have the keys black. But I think it would be cooler to have a black book with a white keyboard.

 

[Temujin]

Aren't you guys concerned with the layer of silicone preventing heat from escaping through the keyboard? Or is it not an issue?

 

[sierra oscar]

Aren't you guys concerned with the layer of silicone preventing heat from escaping through the keyboard? Or is it not an issue?

this is my concern also - I thought the keyboard was an avenue for heat to escape - but maybe that isn't true.

 

[Warbrain]

Aren't you guys concerned with the layer of silicone preventing heat from escaping through the keyboard? Or is it not an issue?

Hasn't been an issue on the iBooks. There are the vents that are by the screen that provide a lot of heat to escape.

 

[sierra oscar]

Having just retired my iMac pro keyboard - due to its rather unkempt condition - and I've purchased the updated mac keyboard - and decided to get an iSkin.

Whilst I will also get an iSkin for my portable - I'm not sure (given this experience with my desktop keyboard) that it's that usable (for me).

I've only been typing with it for about a week - however I'm struggling to type - the 'b' and the 'spacebar' are really difficult - and b/c I need to type quickly to churn work out - it's really slowing me down. The amount of typos due to the lag in my key execution is alarming, not to mention words without spaces.

Hoping my iSkin will settle in a bit more... Not sure if I will shell out money for the iSkin for my new portable at this stage...

 

[jamone80]

another thing to consider with iSkins is the dirt/buildup that might press onto the screen when closed. just a thought...

 

[kainjow]

Having just retired my iMac pro keyboard - due to its rather unkempt condition - and I've purchased the updated mac keyboard - and decided to get an iSkin.

Whilst I will also get an iSkin for my portable - I'm not sure (given this experience with my desktop keyboard) that it's that usable (for me).

I've only been typing with it for about a week - however I'm struggling to type - the 'b' and the 'spacebar' are really difficult - and b/c I need to type quickly to churn work out - it's really slowing me down. The amount of typos due to the lag in my key execution is alarming, not to mention words without spaces.

Hoping my iSkin will settle in a bit more... Not sure if I will shell out money for the iSkin for my new portable at this stage...

I just bought an iSkin for my keyboard too, but the space bar is extremely hard to press. I was able to improve it, but shortly after with just a little more use, it goes back to being very stiff and hard to press. What a waste of $25... I would will never recommend an iSkin for external keyboards.

But I am interested in their MacBook one, since that is flat and would probably not be as much of a hindrance.

 

[freshS0LE]

I'm using one for my MBP and i love it.

it takes getting used to. it really helps to protect
the keyboard and internal from dust accumulations.

another cool thing about it is that is makes typing
silent.

so it's not for everyone but if you want to keep your
keyboard immaculate, definitely get this.

 

[mannix87]

another thing to consider with iSkins is the dirt/buildup that might press onto the screen when closed. just a thought...

hmm. i never thought of that. something new to consider....

 

[sierra oscar]

I just bought an iSkin for my keyboard too, but the space bar is extremely hard to press. I was able to improve it, but shortly after with just a little more use, it goes back to being very stiff and hard to press. What a waste of $25... I would will never recommend an iSkin for external keyboards.

But I am interested in their MacBook one, since that is flat and would probably not be as much of a hindrance.

An update on the iSkin for the ext keyboard - as you know kainjow the space bar was just about unworkable - but is only now starting to show some give and I'm now seeing spaces between my words. But you have to persevere for a few weeks for this to happen. Then again perhaps my typing technique has changed to compensate for this iSkin...not sure.

I wouldn't throw it away though Kainjow (believe me I wanted to - but it cost me allot more than $25.00 from an Australian supplier + postage - so I just couldn't not use it) - but I did think (and I still may do this) to cut out the space bar portion of the iSkin with a scalpel - wouldn't hurt if your iSkin isn't friendly enough to use?

I do think the iSkin (and equivalents) for the MB/MBP will be easier to type with.

 

[freshS0LE]

another thing to consider with iSkins is the dirt/buildup that might press onto the screen when closed. just a thought...

actually...dirt build-up on the silicone doesn't really stick
on the screen. you get some, but it isnt a major problem.
and cmon...ur afraid of a little dust on ur screen? just
brush it off. no biggie.