Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jammer08

macrumors member
Original poster
May 26, 2006
63
0
I ordered a white macbook today, and am reading these threads... I am completely torn... WHITE VS BLACK???... :confused: these posts about the discoloration of the white ones are kinda scaring me... any input on this issue would be great! thanks
 
I wouldnt worry about it too much, I just saw some topics regarding this and it seems if you clean them with non-acetone fingernail polish it turns it good as new. Ive also heard that some of the black macbooks are chipping. I would personally go with the white.
 
FirePak said:
I wouldnt worry about it too much, I just saw some topics regarding this and it seems if you clean them with non-acetone fingernail polish it turns it good as new. Ive also heard that some of the black macbooks are chipping. I would personally go with the white.

Thanks for the response. I have had an iBook for serveral years and experienced no discoloration. I just hope I havn't made the wrong choice with going with the white. First I ordered the black, and then canceled it and re-did the order in white.
 
FirePak said:
I wouldnt worry about it too much, I just saw some topics regarding this and it seems if you clean them with non-acetone fingernail polish it turns it good as new. Ive also heard that some of the black macbooks are chipping. I would personally go with the white.

The black macbooks aren't chipping. They aren't painted, so it is impossible for them to chip/flake. The "incident" about that one guy's macbook was proven to be false.
 
it5five said:
The black macbooks aren't chipping. They aren't painted, so it is impossible for them to chip/flake. The "incident" about that one guy's macbook was proven to be false.

Yeah you're right. I own the Black model and the color is not painted on but its just black plastic. The white model seems too tacky and feminine to me, although the black shows off oil stains, fingerprints and dust way too easily.
 
JackSYi said:
Yeah you're right. I own the Black model and the color is not painted on but its just black plastic. The white model seems too tacky and feminine to me, although the black shows off oil stains, fingerprints and dust way too easily.

How does the black one look? Would you buy the black again if you could go back?
 
it5five said:
The black macbooks aren't chipping. They aren't painted, so it is impossible for them to chip/flake. The "incident" about that one guy's macbook was proven to be false.

it definitely doesn't chip or flake BUT my black macbook had small white spots (if you pick at them, they don't come off and it def. doesn't flake but it seems that the lid was not completely smooth before they applied the black so i had these little clusters of "white crumbs" all over the lid). it also had small bumps, bubbles (again, i think they did not smooth out the lide before applying the black).....some people probably didn't care and yes, i know, it will eventually get nicks, but for 2 G's......
 
Good to know its not chipping or flaking like i previously thought. I just had a friend this morning ask about which he should get, I caught him about 5 mins ago just about to buy the white one he quickly changed his mind and got the black. Thanks for the correct info =)
 
jammer08 said:
How does the black one look? Would you buy the black again if you could go back?

You know, I wouldn't get the white. My choices were between the 15" MacBook Pro and the Black MacBook and because the 15" is just too big for me (I had a 15" PowerBook) black is the only option. So yeah I would get it again if I went back in time. However, ideally I wish Apple made an anodized black aluminum enclosure because the black MacBook shows oil streaks, fingerprints and dust way too easily, but something I can deal with. It is VERY sleek, pictures don't do it justice, in fact I think it makes it look unattractive.
 
jammer08 said:
I ordered a white macbook today, and am reading these threads... I am completely torn... WHITE VS BLACK???... :confused: these posts about the discoloration of the white ones are kinda scaring me... any input on this issue would be great! thanks



My macbook is actually coming in tommorow. Im planning on going black just for this reason. I already talked to the Apple store near me if I can exchange it for a black one, and they already said I could.


I dont know what FirePak is talking about because many people who actually have the discoloration say that using nail polish, some eraser thing, and alcohol does not work. Only some people have gotten lucky for it to work.


Despite the black macbook being able to show dust, scratches, and oils really easily. I rather have those things be shown where I can easily clear them up with a alcohol wipe or some crystal base that can rid of scratches, than to have a huge yellow blotch that has no way to be taken off. Even if there is a small chance, Apple can always pull a fast one on you saying that Applecare does not cover the cosmetics of the system, which leaves you to one dirty macbook.


I went to the Apple store recently just to check out this problem. Although it isnt as bad as the pictures surfing around on the web, it sure doesnt look appealing either, and seems to confirm there is indeed a problem.
 
jammer08 said:
I ordered a white macbook today, and am reading these threads... I am completely torn... WHITE VS BLACK???... :confused: these posts about the discoloration of the white ones are kinda scaring me... any input on this issue would be great! thanks

What i dont get is if the ibooks werent having these issues then the macbook shouldnt be. This whole discoloration issue is rediculous. The dentist guy or whoever started it was suffering from paranoia and lack of a bar of soap. Whats more likely? The macbooks are suffering from a massive discoloration issue that nobody can even prove to be a real issue, or in fact the orginal poster didnt wash his hands well? Common sense people. Ive had my white ibook for over a year now and ive only cleaned it once. Its still white as snow and im a autobody tech by day. I ofton use my computer after work and my hands are very dirty. I think i can speak for some other macrumors members when i say im sick of seeing this so called issue lingering here and id like to see it tossed into wasteland. :rolleyes:
 
because having clean hands and then sweating cant discolor things? Common sense failed you....



and some people with iBooks did run into this type of trouble as well. However the iBooks started showing these type of things years later. The macbook started to discolor within 3 weeks...
 
wako said:
because having clean hands and then sweating cant discolor things? Common sense failed you....



and some people with iBooks did run into this type of trouble as well. However the iBooks started showing these type of things years later. The macbook started to discolor within 3 weeks...

How do you know its caused by sweat? You dont. How do you know what causes it at all? Oh thats right, you dont.
 
How do you know people didnt wash their hands? You dont. How do you know peoples hands were dirty? Oh thats right, you dont.
 
wako said:
My macbook is actually coming in tommorow. Im planning on going black just for this reason. I already talked to the Apple store near me if I can exchange it for a black one, and they already said I could.


I dont know what FirePak is talking about because many people who actually have the discoloration say that using nail polish, some eraser thing, and alcohol does not work. Only some people have gotten lucky for it to work.


Despite the black macbook being able to show dust, scratches, and oils really easily. I rather have those things be shown where I can easily clear them up with a alcohol wipe or some crystal base that can rid of scratches, than to have a huge yellow blotch that has no way to be taken off. Even if there is a small chance, Apple can always pull a fast one on you saying that Applecare does not cover the cosmetics of the system, which leaves you to one dirty macbook.


I went to the Apple store recently just to check out this problem. Although it isnt as bad as the pictures surfing around on the web, it sure doesnt look appealing either, and seems to confirm there is indeed a problem.

Yeah, I decided to cancel my order for the white MB and go with the black... I really don't want any issues.
 
CaptainCaveMann said:
What i dont get is if the ibooks werent having these issues then the macbook shouldnt be. This whole discoloration issue is rediculous. The dentist guy or whoever started it was suffering from paranoia and lack of a bar of soap. Whats more likely? The macbooks are suffering from a massive discoloration issue that nobody can even prove to be a real issue, or in fact the orginal poster didnt wash his hands well? Common sense people. Ive had my white ibook for over a year now and ive only cleaned it once. Its still white as snow and im a autobody tech by day. I ofton use my computer after work and my hands are very dirty. I think i can speak for some other macrumors members when i say im sick of seeing this so called issue lingering here and id like to see it tossed into wasteland. :rolleyes:

Well I would assume that this is the correct place to discuss "Mac Rumors." Feel free to correct me if I am mistaken. ;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.