Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

gvyn24

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 7, 2024
3
0
Hello,

For some background, my MBP (13" Early 2011) running macOS High Sierra suddenly stopped charging after I drained it to 0%. When i plugged it in to turn it on, the battery icon stayed at a constant 0% even after charging it overnight. This prompted me to replace the battery due to the message: "Condition: Replace now," which was why I thought that the battery was dead and refusing to charge. After replacing the battery, I left it to charge for a few hours. At that point, the charger lit up orange whereas previously it was only green. When i came back, I was surprised to find that it had only charged from 19% (amount of charge that came with the replacement battery) to 23% with the message: "battery not charging, power source: power adapter." Many SMC and PRAM resets later, checking if the issue still persists in safe boot and recovery mode, discharging the battery until the macbook goes to sleep then trying to charge it, trying another power adapter, and cleaning out the magsafe connections, it still displays the same behavior but now stuck on 2%. This continued until the time I started writing this post, when the light on the magsafe connector suddenly turned orange and the battery menu displaying either: "0:XX Until Full, Power Source: Power Adapter," where the time was between 0:10 to 0:20, (which I found odd as that seems a little too fast to charge it fully) or "Calculating Time Until Full... Power Source: Power Adapter," which it is still stuck on until now, with the battery level still at 2%.

Now I'm wondering if this is a hardware or software problem but I haven't gone forward with trying a fresh install of macOS to try and rule out any possible causes or even fix the issue altogether as it would be pretty tedious to copy all my important files and setup everything again.

Is there anything else I should try that might resolve the issue or should I just wipe everything and go for a fresh install? I'll be sure to update you guys with anything that happens.

Your help would be greatly appreciated!

UPDATE: As I'm right about to post this, the battery message has gone back to: "Battery not charging, Power Source: Power Adapter" for a short while then switching to: "More than 10 Hours," power source still the same. The magsafe charger switched from orange to green for a minute, then switched back to orange. According to the system information window, the charge remaining on the battery has increased from 129 mAh to 133 mAh in the last ~20 mins.
 

Fishrrman

macrumors Penryn
Feb 20, 2009
29,215
13,285
Is this the factory-original battery?
Or... is it a replacement?

Either way...

If it's the original battery, well, they don't last forever, you know.

If it's a replacement... with battery replacements, it's kind of a crapshoot. Like Forrest Gump with his box of chocolates, "you never know what you're going to get"...

After 13 years, it might be time to start shopping for a new or late-model-used Mac, in any case...
 

gvyn24

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 7, 2024
3
0
Is this the factory-original battery?
Or... is it a replacement?

Either way...

If it's the original battery, well, they don't last forever, you know.

If it's a replacement... with battery replacements, it's kind of a crapshoot. Like Forrest Gump with his box of chocolates, "you never know what you're going to get"...

After 13 years, it might be time to start shopping for a new or late-model-used Mac, in any case...
The original battery was the one that died (or so i assume..) after it was drained to 0%. I replaced it after that with the one that is currently very slowly charging.

Anyway, I'll probably try the last few options I have to troubleshoot this thing until I can put it to rest for good.
 

DeltaMac

macrumors G5
Jul 30, 2003
13,751
4,577
Delaware
Where did you purchase the "slowly charging" battery? If it is old stock, and possibly in the box/new, for a few years, then may simply not be taking a charge. If this was a recent purchase, you might try to get a replacement (yours might have failed through age, when it has never been charged since new.
I would likely try replacing the DC-in board. That might be the reason that you have intermittent charging, and is the easiest part to find, when you have problems with the charging/power on your MBPro. iFixit.com has good repair steps for that replacment, should you decide to try the DC-in board.
 

gvyn24

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 7, 2024
3
0
Where did you purchase the "slowly charging" battery? If it is old stock, and possibly in the box/new, for a few years, then may simply not be taking a charge. If this was a recent purchase, you might try to get a replacement (yours might have failed through age, when it has never been charged since new.
I would likely try replacing the DC-in board. That might be the reason that you have intermittent charging, and is the easiest part to find, when you have problems with the charging/power on your MBPro. iFixit.com has good repair steps for that replacment, should you decide to try the DC-in board.
It was purchased on Shopee, pretty much the Amazon of Southeast Asia. I'm quite sure it's not old stock as coconutBattery says that its manufacture date was September of last year.

I'll definitely try replacing the DC-in board as I noticed that it was quite worn while cleaning it. Thanks!
 
Last edited:

wordsworth

macrumors 6502
Apr 7, 2011
328
283
UK
My guess is that the replacement battery you bought is no good. Indeed, a suitable fully-working battery for a 2011 MacBook Pro will be very difficult to source. Here in the UK one can do just that and get a reliable 2-Power battery for your model of laptop.


I recommend this brand of batteries and bought one (a different battery though in the 2-Power range) for an early 2009 white MacBook and it continues to serve its purpose reliably. If you can get a 2-Power battery, then that is the way to go. I am not sure how widely they are marketed in other countries, however.

I believe, more and more, that almost the entire market in replacement batteries for old machines is merely a quick way for the purchaser to waste their money. When I bought an old iBook the seller kindly replaced the failed battery with a new one, which failed within a day or so of my receipt of it, with the charger displaying similar symptoms to your own. The battery was just no good and not worth even the smallish amount of money it would have cost to buy it.

Of course, there may be a different problem with your laptop but the right reliable battery would be my first choice for a solution.

Here’s some further information about the batteries on 2-Power’s website: https://2-power.com/products/laptop-batteries/
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gvyn24
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.