MBP back to iMac - which one

[HBOC]

some history. Bought a base model 2011 iMac when they came out in 2011. Sold that machine a little over a year ago and bought a new mid 2015 MBP with most options available (minus 1TB SSD and the faster processor). Both machines have served me well.

When I was deciding on what computer to get, i was split between the two options. However i figured i would travel more with the MBP, but i don't. I bought a hi-rise stand, newest magic mouse and keyboard . So realistically my MBP is used as a desktop unit.

Right now i am pondering selling my MBP (had Applecare until Feb 2019) and picking up an iMac, as i would benefit from the larger screen and more ports.

The question I have is how much faster (if any) is my current MBP with the quad core i7 over the quad core i5 on the iMac. The iMac i had before wasn't super slow, but wasn't a speed demon. I would like to put in an SSD (or get one with an SSD).

My uses for the computer are primarily for design - no video work. Photography is the biggest use, and now i am shooting film, so the scans i am doing are 60MB (+/-) and may be moving to medium/large format soon.
Perhaps the base model 27" 5K image will due and then upgrade RAM and SSD?

 

[1050792]

The Base i5 with upgraded SSD + RAM will be more than enough for your needs.
Unless you need hyper threading I wouldn't recommend an i7 as It will just cause more heat especially on these newer iMacs as I heard.

 

[Fishrrman]

Definitely get the 27" iMac. You'll never regret it.

DO get an SSD instead of the fusion drive.
The 512gb SSD adds $300 to the buy-in price. The 256gb adds $100.
IMPORTANT: You must special order these through the "build-to-order" page at store.apple.com. However, a few online resellers may offer them pre-built (I've used portableone.com in the past).

I'd suggest spending $200 more for the "midrange" 3.5ghz model with the 7600 CPU and slightly improved graphics.

 

[Bryan Bowler]

And do not pay for any extra RAM when ordering your iMac. You’ll save a ton of money upgrading it on your own.

 

[maflynn]

The iMac i had before wasn't super slow, but wasn't a speed demon. I would like to put in an SSD (or get one with an SSD).

The iMac is a fast machine, and the 27" model is a great option.

Perhaps the base model 27" 5K image will due and then upgrade RAM and SSD?

Definitely put your $$ towards the SSD. The ram is user replaceable, but the SSD is not. The performance will definitely be noticeable.