Ok, maybe not so great since it breaks more frequently than it should, and the cost for repair is ridiculous. I had my MBP repaired for free fortunately, and Apple does have the repair program. However, after upgrading to a new MBA, I actually miss the old keyboard. It is not as comfortable to type in because of the lack of travel, but I think purely from a design standpoint, the flat keyboard looks slick! I just wish Apple figured out how to make it have more travel or comfortable to type in, and also made repairs easier. I'm sure this was a Ives invention, and now that he is gone, Apple is going to more practical designs, but at the same time, the designs aren't going to be as good (but more practical!).
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
MBP flat keyboard - actually great?
- Thread starter heifetz7
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
im a big fan of the 2021 MBP keyboard. best keyboard out of all the apple keyboards. im a big stickler for key press feel
I had a 2016, 2018 (CRU), and a 2019. The 2016 and 2018 butterfly keyboards were absolute trash. The 2019 was great, and the 2021 is just as good, if not better.
I had to use 2016 and 2017 MBPs with a butterfly keyboard as work machines for quite some time, and also kept a 2018 MBP as a personal device until the M1 Max was released. I ended up having to request a top case replacement on all of them.
I acknowledge Apple's efforts to improve the design over the years, however all revisions failed to solve the underlying reliability issue. After all, you know a design is doomed from the start when a machine is already covered by a replacement program on release day. Good riddance
I acknowledge Apple's efforts to improve the design over the years, however all revisions failed to solve the underlying reliability issue. After all, you know a design is doomed from the start when a machine is already covered by a replacement program on release day. Good riddance
I actually liked the Butterfly keyboard. Took me a bit to get used to, but then it was great.
Reliability though... not so much. I never eat at my MacBook or do other stupid things... but after like 6 months a few keys started misbehaving.
What I actually DO miss though, is the old PowerBook G4/early MBP keyboard, which I think was the best of them all.
Reliability though... not so much. I never eat at my MacBook or do other stupid things... but after like 6 months a few keys started misbehaving.
What I actually DO miss though, is the old PowerBook G4/early MBP keyboard, which I think was the best of them all.
It had too little contrast between the keycap color and the letter color when the backlight was on, though. I think that was the main reason it was phased out.
