Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Does MetaX work for you?

  • Yes

    Votes: 21 84.0%
  • No

    Votes: 4 16.0%

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .

aj350z

macrumors member
Original poster
Sep 17, 2008
73
2
Are there really that many people still having problems with metax?

I have been using it a lot lately for the Mac OS. Both for new movies and old tv shows. It keeps using TagChimp to even find all the data. It even let's me upload to TagChimps site again.

I'm just wondering because I keep seeing post that people are having troubles with MetaX.
 
MetaX works fine. You just have to make sure that your titles do not have stuff appended to them. Ripit and handbrake will often add numbers to the end of the title, especially if you tried ripping and encoding the title several times. You need to make sure your title is correct before you use metaX.
 
I've used both the most recent versions for Windows and Mac and have not had any issues yet (I got a Mac Mini not too long ago and was testing converting/tagging videos on both systems).
 
I tried it and did a big batch of files. In the end, it corrupted about 10% of my files that played just fine before going through MetaX. In some of the corrupted files the audio was stripped out and in the others the audio was present but the video was replaced with black. This was earlier this year with the latest version available at the time.
 
I tried it and did a big batch of files. In the end, it corrupted about 10% of my files that played just fine before going through MetaX. In some of the corrupted files the audio was stripped out and in the others the audio was present but the video was replaced with black. This was earlier this year with the latest version available at the time.

Did you use MakeMKV and included some of the subtitles? I find if I keep those subtitles MetaX will have a problem with the .m4v's from handbrake. I did have that problem last year but haven't since I stopped the subtitles.
 
Same here...

I tried it and did a big batch of files. In the end, it corrupted about 10% of my files that played just fine before going through MetaX. In some of the corrupted files the audio was stripped out and in the others the audio was present but the video was replaced with black. This was earlier this year with the latest version available at the time.

I got tired of the hit and miss nature of MetaX. I haven't had any issues since I switched to Subler.
 
Did you use MakeMKV and included some of the subtitles? I find if I keep those subtitles MetaX will have a problem with the .m4v's from handbrake. I did have that problem last year but haven't since I stopped the subtitles.

Nope. Mine were straight rips from Handbrake with (at the time) default Apple TV settings.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.