Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iphonefreak450

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Dec 14, 2014
839
155
I know that there is a Microsoft Defender Antivirus for MacOS similar to the one built-in on Windows machines.
If I decide to run MS Defender on my Mac, will it automatically disable the Gatekeeper and XProtect?

Or, should I just stick with the built-in security controls using Gatekeeper and XProtect?

What are some suggestions?

What really better does the job?
 
I know that there is a Microsoft Defender Antivirus for MacOS similar to the one built-in on Windows machines.
If I decide to run MS Defender on my Mac, will it automatically disable the Gatekeeper and XProtect?

Or, should I just stick with the built-in security controls using Gatekeeper and XProtect?

What are some suggestions?

What really better does the job?
I use MS Defender on my M1 MBP, signing in with my Microsoft Office Account, and Gatekeeper & XProtect do continue to work normally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaliYoni
no need for third party AV software, just keep macOS up to date, enable gatekeeper and filevault for additional protection
 
  • Like
Reactions: Iwavvns
I only see the need of a AV only if you are on a net with Windows pcs for example, an not to protect the mac, but the windows stations .
 
I know that there is a Microsoft Defender Antivirus for MacOS similar to the one built-in on Windows machines.
If I decide to run MS Defender on my Mac, will it automatically disable the Gatekeeper and XProtect?

Or, should I just stick with the built-in security controls using Gatekeeper and XProtect?

What are some suggestions?

What really better does the job?

No needs, just don't download random things on the Internet. Don't click on random emails that feels like panic mode. Most are phishing.
 
System security like operational security isn't just a buy one product and done. It takes layers.

For layered security, telling somebody don't click the sketchy ads for downloads won't stop them from making a mistake. Adguard, uBlock Origin, Brave, and other technical solutions will. It reduces attack surface and risk of user error. It is one of the best and least invasive changes you can make. You can also look at products from vendors like ESET and Malwarebytes. These are extremely popular products with loads of customers across the internet. Products like that provide a last line of security against zero day exploits or similar long tail problems.

You want your system to be as layered with defenses as you can while still being usable for your daily work. Adblockers, security/malware scanners, and similar transparent measures all help. It all depends on your needs like having an elderly parent who might fall victim to scams.
 
Just realized that it does require a subscription plan as well. No thanks.
If you already have a Microsoft 365 subscription then defender is a great choice, it does not interrupt any other core system functions.

There are other great free options out there if you're not a Microsoft 365 subscriber. I used to use the free Avira solution when I had to have an antivirus installed to access my company's VPN.

There is nothing wrong with putting an antivirus solution on a Mac for added security. Zero day exploits do exist and Apple doesn't have the best record for being responsive. Responsible web usage will largely keep you safe (the same is true on Windows and Linux) but it never hurts to be careful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gank41
MacOS security is a contentious subject. Many say that the built in protections are sufficient. Personally when I lock my door I also use a deadbolt. I want multiple layers of protections so if something slips through one layer the next may catch it. I layer Sophos and Little Snitch over the basic MacOS security. Additional layers include a hardware firewall as well as my internet modem security settings.
 
Defender for Mac isn't necessary. Though, it comes with most Microsoft 365 plans nowadays, so you may end up getting it if you are a current subscriber. It's nothing to fret over, certainly.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.