Try turning off Intertia scrolling.
System Preferences>Accessibility>Mouse & Trackpad>Mouse Options - Select "without inertia" in the drop-down menu.
Also do the obvious. Make sure there are no tiny hairs stuck in the sensor opening on the bottom of the mouse.
Most importantly: Try placing the mouse on a surface other than wood grain or clear glass. Try a matte black or even a sheet of white paper. You would be surprised how many modern mice don't work on a wood grain desk - particularly a medium shade fine grained shiny wood surface.