As recently mentioned in the Movie Thread (linked below), reagarding theater vs director cuts, does anyone remember a director cut that was vastly superior to the theater cut? As a rule, I'd describe them as a way to bloat out a movie in order to generate additional revenue, however sometimes the director cut has some value, but is there enough value to warrant purchase a second copy of a movie, just for the additional footage? Notice I said sometimes and my answer is usually, no.
Here is an example of good extra footage (less than 2 min) in the Avatar Director's cut the areal hunt scene. Granted I am an Avatar junkie:
How can you watch this and not love it?
Regarding Alien, I never saw the Directir's cut, but for Aliens I did and was not happy with the additional footage, which removes all of the mystery of how the Colony on LV426 aliens. We know Burke sent word to the colony in the theatrical cut to go investigate because Ripley said so later in the story, but showing what happens in the beginning, imo removes the entire mystery of them circling the compound and not knowing what exactly happened here, even though we do know. It's a trade off which does not pay off. I'll take the mystery every time.
Aliens Hadley's Hope, this is an example of 5 minutes you don't need to see, followed by Hudson pseudo rapping about what a bad ass he is :
Here is a good addition in the Aliens Director's cut, the sentry turrets :
Here is an example of good extra footage (less than 2 min) in the Avatar Director's cut the areal hunt scene. Granted I am an Avatar junkie:
Regarding Alien, I never saw the Directir's cut, but for Aliens I did and was not happy with the additional footage, which removes all of the mystery of how the Colony on LV426 aliens. We know Burke sent word to the colony in the theatrical cut to go investigate because Ripley said so later in the story, but showing what happens in the beginning, imo removes the entire mystery of them circling the compound and not knowing what exactly happened here, even though we do know. It's a trade off which does not pay off. I'll take the mystery every time.
Aliens Hadley's Hope, this is an example of 5 minutes you don't need to see, followed by Hudson pseudo rapping about what a bad ass he is :
Here is a good addition in the Aliens Director's cut, the sentry turrets :
Starting out with one of the SciFi genres best Ridely Scotts 1979 classic, naturally the theatrical cut
Might stay on the SciFi theme or flip to the Cold War later tonight...
Q-6
Last edited: