My big Purify vs 1Blocker Test

[odoy]

Procedure:
- iOS 9.0.2 @ iPhone 6
- VDSL Telekom (Germany) real 50/10 @ ac-WiFi
- Have not deleted caches. Refresh up to 20 time per site and blocker till i get 5 measures without outliers
- traffic not noted if no changes - except: amazon
- Purify 1.1.1 Settings: Everything turned on, except Images and Scripts
- 1Blocker 1.1 Settings: Everything of the paid Version turned on

Conclusion:
- 1Blocker is 13 %-points faster than Purify
- Purify save 4 %-points more data than 1Blocker
- 1Blocker produce more white space
- If i use Purify, the finished sites feels often very juddery when i scroll

I will use 1Blocker cause the thing with juddery scrolling nerves. maybe it has something to do with the white space.
l have read somewhere you can't delete white space with some general rules. its dynamic, depend on size of the the whit space. can anyone correct me?
Update 1: seems to be fixed with iOS 9.1, but i stay with 1blocker
Update 2: don't want to repeat this test again with 9.1 but i checked two sites and it looks the same.
purify save a little more data and 1blocker is about 15% faster.

btw. it was the last time i used numbers. its a pain! no-one can tell me apple use numbers for their business

 

[canesalato]

Thanks! It was a very interesting read!
I did not notice the scrolling problem with Purify, but i'm on an Air2 and 6s

 

[canesalato]

Thanks! It was a very interesting read!
I did not notice the scrolling problem with Purify, but i'm on an Air2 and 6s

Also: what rules were activated in 1 blocker? Only ads or also trackers?

 

[fjarl]

I switched to 1blocker because Purify just didn't load certain sites. First 1blocker didn't block ads on those sites (mainly Swedish ones), but after their recent rules update, there's no problem. So 1blocker for me as well.

 

[odoy]

Also: what rules were activated in 1 blocker? Only ads or also trackers?

update

 

[Stalyn]

Ok.

 

[canesalato]

update

Thanks

 

[Mercenary]

I use purify and can't fault it but I too noticed the stutter when scrolling. I just thought it was an iOS 9 metal thingy but it now makes sense. Going to give it a go with purify off when 9.1 is installed to see if that fixes it. If it does, I may be switching to 1blockr

 

[Goatllama]

Dang, dude, this is fantastic. Thanks for sharing this info and for the work you put into it.

 

[teknikal90]

I use purify and can't fault it but I too noticed the stutter when scrolling. I just thought it was an iOS 9 metal thingy but it now makes sense. Going to give it a go with purify off when 9.1 is installed to see if that fixes it. If it does, I may be switching to 1blockr

keep us updated

thanks!

 

[Coupz]

I wonder how Crystal would compare against both. I'm using crystal.

Thank you for your work. Greetings from Austria