It doesn't look that bad to me.1- How bad does it look and does it ruin the overall look of the laptop?
Yes, of course it will, though how much, is anyone's guess.2- Does it significantly decrease the overall value of my MBP ?
It won't be covered under warranty, so I'd say its not a good idea.3- Would you ignore it or replace the aluminium case?
1. See how much you had to zoom in to show it to us? I'd say that answers it.My 1 year old 15 inch Retina Macbook pro has a noticable ding on the top case (please check attached photo).
1- How bad does it look and does it ruin the overall look of the laptop?
2- Does it significantly decrease the overall value of my MBP ?
3- Would you ignore it or replace the aluminium case?
Who cares? It's a tool, not a Van Gogh. I don't complain when I get a bit of rust on my hammer.
I've owned at LEAST 15 Apple notebooks in the last 15 years. I upgrade every cycle, and I take very good care of my gear. But it's still a tool. I've always gotten very good resale value with a nick or dent or scratch here or there. People buying used equipment rarely expect it to be flawless. As long as the guts are reliable, they usually don't give a crap.
Yeah right. I know looks don't mean crap to me when I'm buying used electronic goods.
Not!
So a scratch or a dent affects performance?
The comment is based on the premise that a scratch or a dent could be seen as a warning that the system suffered a drop or some other form of physical contact out of the norm that could risk damaging one or more of the internal components, which could in turn affect the system's ability to perform within spec.
Since most people would respond with "caveat emptor" type comments if one were to post on here about how they were scammed by somebody that sold them a system with a scratch or dent, and now it won't boot, or the display stopped working, etc., it shouldn't be scorned if another posts on here wondering if the same could affect resale value.
That's why you put a $2000+ computer through its paces before you buy it used.
You could take some light sandpaper and knock that down to a much less noticeable difference. I had a very small ding on an older MacBook Pro that pissed me off when it happened. I did just did what I said earlier and I could barely tell it was even there. The buyer that bought it from me never noticed it until I pointed it out to him.
Just be careful and do it in very small steps. The aluminum on these laptops is pretty soft.
Oh yeah, like most people do that sort of stuff when they're buying a used laptop. I can see it now:
Buyer: Okay, I want to install some heavy CPU/GPU intensive programs on your item to make sure your machine isn't faulty or damaged.
Selling: Huh??? The machine looks brand new. As you can see, it powers on nicely and runs like it's suppose to.
Buyer: Well, I know the machine looks good on the outside but I want to make sure the insides are fine and up to my tasks.
Seller: Okay, maybe we'd be better off not making the deal after all....
(the seller is shaking his head while walking back towards his car.)
Oh yeah, like most people do that sort of stuff when they're buying a used laptop. I can see it now:
Buyer: Okay, I want to install some heavy CPU/GPU intensive programs on your item to make sure your machine isn't faulty or damaged.
Selling: Huh??? The machine looks brand new. As you can see, it powers on nicely and runs like it's suppose to.
Buyer: Well, I know the machine looks good on the outside but I want to make sure the insides are fine and up to my tasks.
Seller: Okay, maybe we'd be better off not making the deal after all....
(the seller is shaking his head while walking back towards his car.)
I've bought a dozen Macs on Craigslist and sellers have never had a problem with me running disk tests, cross checking serial numbers, and making sure the specs are right.