Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Samuelsan2001

macrumors 604
Oct 24, 2013
7,729
2,153
1. it's a laptop ding it happens it looks like what it is a tool that is used.

2. yes it will decrease the overall value but if you aren't selling it what does that matter? If you are selling in the future the older it is the less a ding will affect the price.

3 of course I'd ignore it it is a minor blemish on a tool I use everyday.
 

maflynn

macrumors Haswell
May 3, 2009
73,682
43,740
1- How bad does it look and does it ruin the overall look of the laptop?
It doesn't look that bad to me.
2- Does it significantly decrease the overall value of my MBP ?
Yes, of course it will, though how much, is anyone's guess.
3- Would you ignore it or replace the aluminium case?
It won't be covered under warranty, so I'd say its not a good idea.
 

Jozone

macrumors 6502
Jul 24, 2007
391
145
Sadly you would be looking at $500+ to fix, which is certainly way more than the amount of money you have lost in resale value. Stick with it, and I am sure you will find a future buyer who doesn't mind (heck if the specs were right, and for a good price, Id happily buy a laptop off CL that looked like that).
 

hallux

macrumors 68040
Apr 25, 2012
3,439
1,005
That's not in the topcase, that's on the LCD clamshell. Replacement of that part would be quite expensive as noted by @Jozone , the "loss" in value of the system by having that little ding would certainly not be equal to the cost to repair. Not worth it.

The topcase is the part containing the keyboard and trackpad.
 

Fishrrman

macrumors Penryn
Feb 20, 2009
29,175
13,223
Whether you want to pay the cost of the repair (which will be high) is up to you.
I'd just use it "as is".

It looks like -only- "cosmetic damage".
Everything still works ok?
 

osnola ibax

macrumors member
Jul 17, 2014
59
55
Would irritate me too I have to say but just forget about it. It's actually not that bad at all. You won't worry about it in a couple of weeks. Stop looking at it (at different angles and lights)
 

squarebreathing

macrumors member
Feb 16, 2016
69
28
Baltimore
Get a rubber case for both the screen and base portions. It will probably hide that ding and help keep other damage from happening in the future. When you choose to sell it, show the ding in pictures and explain it doesn't affect the mac in anyway - usually this won't drop value on it by much at all. As you use a laptop more and more over the course of a few years it is bound to (even with a case) get some dings here and there.
 

snaky69

macrumors 603
Mar 14, 2008
5,908
488
My 1 year old 15 inch Retina Macbook pro has a noticable ding on the top case (please check attached photo).
1- How bad does it look and does it ruin the overall look of the laptop?
2- Does it significantly decrease the overall value of my MBP ?
3- Would you ignore it or replace the aluminium case?
1. See how much you had to zoom in to show it to us? I'd say that answers it.
2. Probably. It wouldn't deter me.
3. Why bother? A laptop's a tool, it's meant to be used, do you replace your hammer when it gets a scratch?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goatllama

ozziegn

macrumors 65816
Aug 16, 2007
1,303
834
Central FL Area
You could take some light sandpaper and knock that down to a much less noticeable difference. I had a very small ding on an older MacBook Pro that pissed me off when it happened. I did just did what I said earlier and I could barely tell it was even there. The buyer that bought it from me never noticed it until I pointed it out to him.

Just be careful and do it in very small steps. The aluminum on these laptops is pretty soft.
 

ValiumEater

macrumors regular
Dec 14, 2015
113
132
Who cares? It's a tool, not a Van Gogh. I don't complain when I get a bit of rust on my hammer.
 

ozziegn

macrumors 65816
Aug 16, 2007
1,303
834
Central FL Area
Who cares? It's a tool, not a Van Gogh. I don't complain when I get a bit of rust on my hammer.

Well that's fine if you don't ever plan on selling your hammer hoping to get top dollar. People like myself upgrade our electronic toys quite often so keeping them in pristine condition is critical for maximum resale vale.
 

ValiumEater

macrumors regular
Dec 14, 2015
113
132
I've owned at LEAST 15 Apple notebooks in the last 15 years. I upgrade every cycle, and I take very good care of my gear. But it's still a tool. I've always gotten very good resale value with a nick or dent or scratch here or there. People buying used equipment rarely expect it to be flawless. As long as the guts are reliable, they usually don't give a crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goatllama

ozziegn

macrumors 65816
Aug 16, 2007
1,303
834
Central FL Area
I've owned at LEAST 15 Apple notebooks in the last 15 years. I upgrade every cycle, and I take very good care of my gear. But it's still a tool. I've always gotten very good resale value with a nick or dent or scratch here or there. People buying used equipment rarely expect it to be flawless. As long as the guts are reliable, they usually don't give a crap.

Yeah right. I know looks don't mean crap to me when I'm buying used electronic goods.

Not!
 

duervo

macrumors 68020
Feb 5, 2011
2,476
1,248
So a scratch or a dent affects performance?

The comment is based on the premise that a scratch or a dent could be seen as a warning that the system suffered a drop or some other form of physical contact out of the norm that could risk damaging one or more of the internal components, which could in turn affect the system's ability to perform within spec.

Since most people would respond with "caveat emptor" type comments if one were to post on here about how they were scammed by somebody that sold them a system with a scratch or dent, and now it won't boot, or the display stopped working, etc., it shouldn't be scorned if another posts on here wondering if the same could affect resale value.
 

ValiumEater

macrumors regular
Dec 14, 2015
113
132
The comment is based on the premise that a scratch or a dent could be seen as a warning that the system suffered a drop or some other form of physical contact out of the norm that could risk damaging one or more of the internal components, which could in turn affect the system's ability to perform within spec.

Since most people would respond with "caveat emptor" type comments if one were to post on here about how they were scammed by somebody that sold them a system with a scratch or dent, and now it won't boot, or the display stopped working, etc., it shouldn't be scorned if another posts on here wondering if the same could affect resale value.

That's why you put a $2000+ computer through its paces before you buy it used.
 

spiderman0616

Suspended
Aug 1, 2010
5,670
7,499
I gotta say--that would drive me nuts.

On the advice of another member here (I forget who it was), when I got my new 13" rMBP last year, I put a BestSkinsEver matte finish skin on it to avoid scratches and scuffs, and then got a padded sleeve to avoid dings when I'm carrying it around. I like the skins because nobody notices they're on there, and the plastic covers tend to trap dirt and grit underneath and scratch up the laptop anyway.

I would say get a skin for it. It will prevent more of this in the future, and it might even hide the damage a little bit. Out of sight, out of mind.
 

ozziegn

macrumors 65816
Aug 16, 2007
1,303
834
Central FL Area
That's why you put a $2000+ computer through its paces before you buy it used.

Oh yeah, like most people do that sort of stuff when they're buying a used laptop. I can see it now:

Buyer: Okay, I want to install some heavy CPU/GPU intensive programs on your item to make sure your machine isn't faulty or damaged.
Selling: Huh??? The machine looks brand new. As you can see, it powers on nicely and runs like it's suppose to.
Buyer: Well, I know the machine looks good on the outside but I want to make sure the insides are fine and up to my tasks.
Seller: Okay, maybe we'd be better off not making the deal after all....

(the seller is shaking his head while walking back towards his car.)
 

jlc1978

macrumors 603
Aug 14, 2009
5,858
4,817
You could take some light sandpaper and knock that down to a much less noticeable difference. I had a very small ding on an older MacBook Pro that pissed me off when it happened. I did just did what I said earlier and I could barely tell it was even there. The buyer that bought it from me never noticed it until I pointed it out to him.

Just be careful and do it in very small steps. The aluminum on these laptops is pretty soft.

Sandpaper will also change the color of the area - so it's a tossup as to what is worse. I have an older MBP with a worse ding and a LCD screen I replaced my self after I broke the screen. The machine works fine and so even with a big dent in the cover I saw no reason to pay a whole bunch to fix a cosmetic blemish. YMMV
[doublepost=1458411208][/doublepost]
Oh yeah, like most people do that sort of stuff when they're buying a used laptop. I can see it now:

Buyer: Okay, I want to install some heavy CPU/GPU intensive programs on your item to make sure your machine isn't faulty or damaged.
Selling: Huh??? The machine looks brand new. As you can see, it powers on nicely and runs like it's suppose to.
Buyer: Well, I know the machine looks good on the outside but I want to make sure the insides are fine and up to my tasks.
Seller: Okay, maybe we'd be better off not making the deal after all....

(the seller is shaking his head while walking back towards his car.)

However, running basic diagnostics is not a bad idea.
 

ValiumEater

macrumors regular
Dec 14, 2015
113
132
Oh yeah, like most people do that sort of stuff when they're buying a used laptop. I can see it now:

Buyer: Okay, I want to install some heavy CPU/GPU intensive programs on your item to make sure your machine isn't faulty or damaged.
Selling: Huh??? The machine looks brand new. As you can see, it powers on nicely and runs like it's suppose to.
Buyer: Well, I know the machine looks good on the outside but I want to make sure the insides are fine and up to my tasks.
Seller: Okay, maybe we'd be better off not making the deal after all....

(the seller is shaking his head while walking back towards his car.)

If I'm dropping $2k on a used computer that comes from who knows where, you're damn right I'm going to test it out first. I've bought a dozen Macs on Craigslist and sellers have never had a problem with me running disk tests, cross checking serial numbers, and making sure the specs are right. I'm not talking about installing Avid and editing a feature on it, just making sure the storage, RAM and processor aren't f***ed up.
 

LxHunter

Suspended
Nov 14, 2010
502
72
I've bought a dozen Macs on Craigslist and sellers have never had a problem with me running disk tests, cross checking serial numbers, and making sure the specs are right.

Yes same here, but as a seller.
I have sold a few MacBooks on Kijiji andCraigslist.
To protect myself I insist the buyer does more tests and checks than they usually want to.
Some buyers are less experienced and I don't want problems to arise after sale.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.