Wes said:Is this your guess or do you have some inside info?
Fat Tony said:I just bought the new Beastie Boys
bertagert said:I think the videos are only shown through the store (not on the ipod its self). Do you guys really think viewing video on an ipod would be important?
macguymike said:Free single of the week!![]()
bertagert said:I'm guessing the songs that we have already purchased can be burned 7 times right? This is done through 4.5 and not the DRM in the file right?
Horrortaxi said:Good question. I've wondered this since iTMS started, but never needed to burn a playlist 10 (now 7) times to find out the answer. How does iTunes know how many times you've burned a playlist? Is it in the preferences? If you max out burning of a playlist and then delete the playlist, if you recreate it do you get another 7 burns? Or is it stored in the AAC file, so it knows which playlists it's been on? What if you rearrange the order of songs in a playlist? Does that count as a different playlist? Or if you just rename the playlist, is it a different playlist?
Overall I'm happy with the new rules. They decreased the number of times you can burn a playlist and took away unlimited iPods, but those are issues that never effected me. The raised the number of Macs you can authorize to 5, which is a good thing for me. For the average person with 1 computer and 1 iPod they won't even know the difference.
I think it was in the 4.5 EULA.RHutch said:Where did you read that they took away unlimited iPods? I have read about this story in several places today, and I am sure that I read that you can still put your purchased music on an unlimited number of iPods.
Horrortaxi said:I think it was in the 4.5 EULA.
Horrortaxi said:Good question. I've wondered this since iTMS started, but never needed to burn a playlist 10 (now 7) times to find out the answer. How does iTunes know how many times you've burned a playlist? Is it in the preferences? If you max out burning of a playlist and then delete the playlist, if you recreate it do you get another 7 burns? Or is it stored in the AAC file, so it knows which playlists it's been on? What if you rearrange the order of songs in a playlist? Does that count as a different playlist? Or if you just rename the playlist, is it a different playlist?
Overall I'm happy with the new rules. They decreased the number of times you can burn a playlist and took away unlimited iPods, but those are issues that never effected me. The raised the number of Macs you can authorize to 5, which is a good thing for me. For the average person with 1 computer and 1 iPod they won't even know the difference.
That may be correct, but at least somewhere was reporting that simply rearranging the playlist will NOT allow you to re-burn it. Minor annoyance, since most people really don't have much reason to burn more than 7 identical CDs unless they're giving away copies to everybody they know--one each for a couple of cars, one for your bookbag, one for home, and a couple to replace the ones that you loose, and you've still got one left over. Can always re-rip and re-burn or just do a direct copy of the CD if it matters that much, anyway.Don't panic said:you can burn up to 7 CONSECUTIVE and IDENTICAL playlists.
any change will re-zero the count.
I mostly agree, but this is only partly true; if you don't upgrade to version 4.5 of iTunes, you are not subject to the new restrictions. So although it is indeed a licence, it's connected to the player software, not the music. Subtle difference, but it is important to a degree. And again, once you've burned a CD, that is your legit piece of music on the CD, free of any added-after-the-fact restrictions.Don't panic said:I relly think that in practical term it's an irrelevant change. However, in principle, they changed an agreement and it sets a precedent. if they can do that any time they want, that's not good, because ay one point they might decide to change it to a much more restrictive DRM. basically it's not true that you purchased the music. It's more like a license.