Yeah, but the whole point of this thread is that Perfect Browse is currently free, so grab it as a Plan B now, just in case. Committing more stuff to Aperture just means more work down the line.
And it doesn't make sense to compare this to Aperture and say that it doesn't give you an import view as Aperture did; Perfect Browse BROWSES, it doesn't import. What you see is what you get; in fact, it's better at showing what Aperture shows in the Import view since you see more info and can do more with that view. In Aperture you have to wait until it imports; meanwhile, in Perfect Browser you're already adding metadata or sending a file to an editor. That's the point of a browser vs a PIE like Aperture (although the PIE's do have some advantages obviously).
Not sure I get what you're saying. The purpose of this app is similar to Photo Mechanic. A front-end to Aperture or Lightroom. Certainly not a replacement. With its Import to Aperture or LR function, it is committing more "stuff" to Aperture.
I'm a Photo a Mechanic user, as a front end to Aperture. But I might switch over to Perfect Browse. It's a friendlier interface, as quick, if not quicker and pretty much does what I need.
Where I find it lacking is no compare view. If On One is going to pitch a front-end, they should realize people probably want to compare some shots, side by side, perhaps at a pixel level before import. Perhaps I'm an anomaly. If people tend to keep every shot they take, an app like this makes no sense. I tend to cull 75% of my shots before import and PB or PM are valuable tools.
Just read your Pre-LR topic. Understood.