Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

cinderjack

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jan 18, 2025
2
0
Hi all - long-time Mac user but new to this forum.

I have 3 different business and a couple email addresses for each so as you can imagine my email inbox is a disaster. I'm looking for some advice on organizing and handling incoming emails.

Last year as a big organization effort, I created an email address specifically for sorting emails from all the different email addresses (I'll call it sort@domain.com). I created folders under that email address and as things come in that I need to keep for a while (receipts, newsletters I might need to refer to in the future, conversations I need to keep an "archive" of, etc). That's been working "ok", but maybe someone has a better suggestion for how to organize emails I mostly need for future reference, but don't actively want in my inbox anymore. So that's Part A of my question.

Part B is: I'd love to be able to have a couple different email inboxes or a way to look at a grouping of email addresses at once without having to look at them all. (As an example, I have 6 email addresses I'd consider important. They are once they I need to read, analyze, respond to, file, etc. I also have 2 emails for appointment bookings, etc. I tried to handle this through Smart folders with the following setup:

"contains message that match *Any* of the following conditions:"
Any recipient - is equal to - [emailaddress1] +
Any recipient - is equal to - [emailaddress2]

But...this shows emails that have been previously moved into my filing (sort@domain.com).

If I add a criteria for only being in my inbox, this I get all emails addressed to both email addresses, plus all in my inbox...which is all emails.

I'm trying to do 1) all emails addressed to either of those 2 recipients and 2) is in my inbox.

Any suggestions? I'm open to other mail apps if anyone has had luck organizing emails in this manner...but would prefer to solve it with Mac Mail if possible.
 
It seems you can narrow a Smart Mailbox down to a specific recipient [emailaddress1] and a specific folder [Inbox] (using the match "all" condition) but I don't see a way to narrow one down to two recipients and the Inbox.

But…you can create a Smart Mailbox for each of the two recipients and the Inbox and then create a third Smart Mailbox to show everything in both of the other two Smart Mailboxes.

I don't see any issue with your organization method using the seperate account. Having multiple email accounts in Mail makes for a long and messy Sidebar and that's true for my situation with only two accounts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cinderjack
I use Outlook for Mac, which might be something to look into if you're unable to get things to work the way you'd like in Mail. It's free and can be found in the App Store (link).
  • You can have multiple profiles and specify which email accounts show for each profile. You can switch between profiles easily in the sidebar.
    • You could have one profile for your six main email addresses, another for your two appointment booking addresses, and another one for your sort address. (Or perhaps have a profile for each of your businesses.)
    • There is also an 'All Accounts' profile, which will show everything.
  • For each profile, you can view an aggregated Inbox/Drafts/Sent/Deleted/etc. for all accounts in that profile. You can still view each account separately, as well.
  • Outlook allows you search by 'Current Mailbox', 'All Mailboxes' (in that profile), 'Current Folder', and 'Subfolders'.
Personally, I sort my mail into folders for the email account it's in, so I can't really comment on that part. FWIW, I've never had a problem finding things, or having things show up in a search when I don't want them to. (I usually know which mailbox or folder to limit my search to.)
 
I use Outlook for Mac, which might be something to look into if you're unable to get things to work the way you'd like in Mail. It's free and can be found in the App Store (link).
  • You can have multiple profiles and specify which email accounts show for each profile. You can switch between profiles easily in the sidebar.
    • You could have one profile for your six main email addresses, another for your two appointment booking addresses, and another one for your sort address. (Or perhaps have a profile for each of your businesses.)
    • There is also an 'All Accounts' profile, which will show everything.
  • For each profile, you can view an aggregated Inbox/Drafts/Sent/Deleted/etc. for all accounts in that profile. You can still view each account separately, as well.
  • Outlook allows you search by 'Current Mailbox', 'All Mailboxes' (in that profile), 'Current Folder', and 'Subfolders'.
Personally, I sort my mail into folders for the email account it's in, so I can't really comment on that part. FWIW, I've never had a problem finding things, or having things show up in a search when I don't want them to. (I usually know which mailbox or folder to limit my search to.)
That's a great idea...to set up different profiles. Thanks!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.